National Scholar Updates

Israel Can Shift the Global Narrative: Offer a Peace Plan

Isn’t it mind-boggling that so many people around the world are spewing hatred for Israel and the Jewish people? It is likely that most of the haters know little or nothing about Israel and have little personal contact with actual Jews.

They thrive on lies and ugly stereotypes. They are not interested in facts or historical perspective: they fill the streets with protests and anti-Israel epithets. If they know next to nothing about the real Israel, they know even less about the real Palestinians and Hamas supporters. 

While we can complain about the outrageous calumnies aimed at us, it would be wise to think more carefully about our current predicament. Yes, there are anti-Zionists who will hate Israel no matter what Israel does or doesn’t do. Yes, there are antisemites who will believe all sorts of conspiracy theories about Jews, no matter how egregiously false and malicious.

But putting aside the incorrigible anti-Zionists and antisemites, there are many people – including Jews – who find themselves more sympathetic to the “Palestinian cause” than to the well-being of Israel. One of the reasons that people are feeling negative about Israel is because Israel is portrayed as the intransigent oppressor of the Palestinian people.

For many, it doesn’t matter if this portrayal is truthful; it only matters that they be seen as fighters for the oppressed. Israel is constantly branded as a pariah state that denies elementary rights to Palestinians. As long as this charge is given credence, we can expect many people – who are not essentially anti-Zionist or anti-Israel – to side with the oppressed rather than with the oppressor.

Israel has done a very poor job in promoting itself as a light unto the nations. It has, sadly, become a lightning rod for hatred, abuse, and calumnies of all kinds.

Creating a future plan for peace

What can be done to improve the situation? One suggestion is for Israel to develop and promote a peace plan for the future. While this will undoubtedly be criticized as being naïve and unrealistic, it is a strategic and a moral step forward for Israel.

We can be fairly certain that Palestinians will reject almost any peace plan that Israel offers, but let the burden fall on them. Let the world know that Israel is doing everything within reason to reach a peaceful situation where Israelis and Palestinians can build a brighter future.

Offering a peace plan is not a sign of weakness but a demonstration of strength. Calling for genuine negotiations with realistic goals provides an opening for a better understanding of Israel’s concerns.

In our prayers, we ask the Almighty to grant strength to His people and to bless His people with peace. It takes tremendous strength to achieve peace. May God grant His people that strength…and a genuine peace.

 

Rabbi Marc D. Angel is director of the Institute for Jewish Ideas and Ideals, and rabbi emeritus of the historic Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue in New York City.


 

No Room For Nazis

“NO ROOM FOR NAZIS”

 

By the Rev. Dr. Michel J. Faulkner, chairman of the board of directors of the Philadelphia Council of Clergy Global.

 

Unfortunately, antisemitism has become chic in some circles. We saw what that looks like in Philadelphia on Sunday, November 8, when a bicycle protest near Rittenhouse Square called for a boycott of six Jewish-owned restaurants. Hundreds of people showed up to support those businesses, many by doing something as ordinary as buying a meal. I am grateful they did. I am also outraged that our Jewish neighbors had to see their businesses singled out on the eve of the anniversary of Kristallnacht.

 

On November 8, 1938, Nazi newspapers blamed Jews collectively for the shooting of a German diplomat in Paris. This was the pretense for attacks on Jewish businesses and synagogues. On the night of November 9 and into November 10, Nazi leaders unleashed a pogrom across Germany and its annexed territories. Synagogues burned. Mobs broke into homes and vandalized thousands of Jewish-owned businesses. Jews were savagely beaten and killed, and German police sent about 26,000 Jewish men to concentration camps. It’s been called “the Night of Broken Glass”, but the glass was the least of what was broken.

 

When I think about Kristallnacht, the hate began before the windows were broken that night. Nazi propaganda had taught people to see their Jewish neighbors were to blame for Germany’s economic decline. By the time the mobs came, some ordinary citizens were willing to join in. When we remember that night, we ought to ask ourselves what we are willing to speak up about in our own time. How often do we hear an antisemitic slur or a conspiracy about Jewish people and let it pass because speaking up would make the room uncomfortable? Why blame Jewish Americans for the war in Gaza? It’s just an excuse for racist antisemitism. 

 

This is why I am so offended when Jewish businesses are singled out here in the City of Brotherly Love. A family running a restaurant in Center City should be able to open its doors, welcome its customers, and earn a living without being made to remember this horrible chapter in human history. Think about what it means for the people who work there to show up for a Sunday shift knowing that their place of work has become a target by haters. We need to take that seriously, even after the crowds have gone home.

 

As an African American, I remember that the racial hatred behind Nazism extended to Black and Brown people, too. The Nazi regime persecuted Black people in Germany and forcibly sterilized some of them, including children. Jewish people were the principal targets of Nazi racial hatred, and we must never forget what was done to them.

 

Growing up in Washington, D.C., during the civil rights movement I remember that many Jewish leaders stood with us in that struggle for equality. A community reveals its character when people are willing to bear some of the cost of standing with their neighbors. In the City of Brotherly Love there is no room for Nazi racist. I know what it means to count on your neighbors to speak when people treat your dignity as a matter of debate. I owe my Jewish neighbors the same solidarity I would ask of them.

 

As a Christian, I stand with the Jewish people and with Israel’s right to exist and thrive. Jesus was a Jew. I believe Christian leaders ought to be among the first to speak when our Jewish neighbors are treated with contempt. Let us teach our congregations what happened on November 9, 1938. Let us call the rabbis in our neighborhoods, listen to what their congregations are experiencing, and ask how we can stand with them. If we have never made that call, this is a good week to pick up the phone.

 

There is no room for Nazis in Philadelphia. I want our Jewish neighbors to hear that from our pulpits and our public officials, and I want them to see it in how we show up for them. The people who lined up to buy lunch on Sunday gave us one way to begin. We can go back next week and learn the owners’ names. When we say we stand with our Jewish neighbors, I want them to know us well enough to believe it.


 

Three Pillars of Inclusive Orthodox Rabbinical Leadership

 

“Inclusive Orthodoxy” was Rabbi Sacks’ way of describing how the majority of Jewish congregations operate in Britain and the Commonwealth. In these communities most synagogues are run along Orthodox lines with an Orthodox Rabbi, and some members who are observant. However, most congregants are more traditional than strict in their religious practice. Nevertheless, they are part of an Orthodox congregation, and when the model is working at its best, they feel at home there, are actively welcomed and valued, and they may even grow in their religious commitment. Beyond their commitment to maintaining Orthodox communal standards, these congregations are not part of a dedicated ideological project of any particular variety, but religious communities that seek to provide a home to as many Jews as possible.

That is the model of the United Synagogue in London, similar congregations around Britain, and in other countries including Canada, New Zealand, South Africa, and my own home in Australia. I have been the Rabbi of one such congregation, The Great Synagogue of Sydney, for just over 10 years now. In that time, I have had to reflect on how a Rabbi can and should lead an Inclusive Orthodox community. It is not straightforward, and raises several quandaries. How can the Rabbi uphold Orthodox standards while still welcoming everyone? How can he make everyone feel at home even though they might have very different lifestyles to his own, and very different from a halakhic ideal? How can he promote increased Jewish observance without alienating his congregation?

I cannot claim to have all the answers to these questions, but I think that the bridge that needs to be built may rest on three pillars: Embracing, Exemplifying, and Encouraging. Just as Rabbi Sacks argued that Inclusive Orthodoxy as a whole was not an accommodation, but an ideal, certainly in the context of the modern world as it actually exists, I submit that this rabbinic approach is not just a strategic choice, but is also a religious imperative.

First comes Embracing. It is the job of the Rabbi of any congregation, and especially a congregation where the members are not uniform in their level of religious observance, to embrace each and every person. My young children have a board book called We Go to Shul (by Douglas Florian and Hannah Tolson), which includes the line, “Rabbi greets all those he meets,” which captures this responsibility perfectly. Everyone who wants to come to any activities of the congregation should be greeted, embraced, genuinely welcomed and valued, and they should feel that is the authentic disposition of the Rabbi. This is a different concept to being non-judgmental.  Choosing not to be judgmental implies that I harbor an unexpressed judgement, and I am making the decision not to bring it out, but it exists and I could if I wanted. Embracing puts all that aside, and sees only a person who wants to connect, and celebrating and facilitating that desire. Although, as I will go on to argue, the Rabbi can and should be ambitious for each person’s religious growth, authentic embrace is not a tool to bring about that growth but a fundamental expression of Jewish values in its own right. When Maimonides codified the obligation to love another Jew in Hilkhot Deot 6:3, he did so without qualification: “Each person is commanded to love each and every one of Israel as themselves.” It is not dependent on the level, actual or prospective, of religious observance.

Sometimes this can be difficult, on a personal or a religious level. Some people are difficult, they are prickly characters, or simply have a personality that does not click with the Rabbi’s. Sometimes the Rabbi may feel frustration or disappointment with a congregant’s religious observance. He might feel the congregant could do more, or has even slipped backward. He might feel that his hopes for that congregant have not borne fruit, or that he has poured care and effort without experiencing reciprocity. There are two ways for the Rabbi to address this, and they are both internal work. The first is to try to set all these considerations aside, and return to the core values of universal and unconditional embrace. If that is not immediately or always possible, then it is worth remembering that religious-pastoral relationships play out over a long time. What does not happen this year may happen next year, or in 10 years.

Patience and persistence are the keys to both a happy and a successful rabbinate. The second pillar is Exemplifying. Yelling at people to do more or do better probably never worked well, and certainly cannot work today. A Rabbi makes clear their standards not by demanding them of others but by living up to them, as much as possible, himself. Again Maimonides points us toward this, when he advises (Hilkhot Talmud Torah 4:1) that however wise a teacher may be, he should only be followed if his behavior exemplifies proper conduct, because teaching ultimately resides in actions more than words. The Rabbi must therefore be scrupulous in how he speaks and what he eats, in timely and reliable attendance at services, visible enthusiasm for the study of Torah, hospitality, generosity, acts of personal kindness. As the Talmud states in Yoma 86a, he should prompt observers to say of him, “how pleasant are his ways, how proper are his deeds.”

This should not make the Rabbi appear angelic, because the Torah was not given to the angels. He can thoughtfully give insight into his struggles because questioning and doubt are inevitable parts of the religious experience, and his congregants should not be misled into believing they alone face these challenges. That would be both dishonest and unhelpful. In a careful way, the Rabbi can share the practical struggles of, say, raising a young family while also attending to religious and communal obligations, or the theological struggles that come from seeing the innocent suffer.

The Rabbi must also demonstrate palpable intellectual integrity and moral clarity. If he feels the need to teach difficult lessons or transmit challenging ideas, he must do so, but not in a way that demands agreement or compliance. The stance of the Rabbi should be: “You have asked me to be your teacher, and that gives me an obligation to teach the truth as I see it. No one is obliged to agree with me, but you have a right to know what I think if I believe the circumstances call on me to tell you.”

That combination of courage and conviction with humility and openness is a contribution in itself and also makes even the hardest messages possible to give and receive without destabilizing relationships. They reveal a Rabbi who might be wrong, and knows he might be wrong, but who is not prepared to be a liar or a coward. Of course, knowing when not to speak, and how not to speak is just as important, and verbal recklessness is no more a quality in a Rabbi than it is in anyone else. What is true, is that with the growth of love and trust, more can be said.

Have I detailed impossibly high standards? Probably. Which means in turn there can be modeling of living with imperfection, honesty about falling short, the need for repair following rupture, and a continual attempt to do better.

The final pillar is Encouraging. The challenge is to nudge without becoming a "noodge." In an Inclusive Orthodox congregation, the Rabbi cannot rely on a shared understanding of the practical binding force of halakha, or on peer pressure and social expectations, but he still wants to see his congregants grow in their religious observance. He is not presiding over what is sometimes called a “kiruv shul,” a place where everyone is consciously and deliberately on a journey toward greater religious observance and where they want the Rabbi to help them on that path. That is probably not the project or the consensus of the membership of an Inclusive Orthodox community. What, then, can the Rabbi do? He can and should encourage. He should engage with his congregants, as Maimonides counsels “patiently and gently” (Hilkhot Deot 6:7). Suggesting to someone who rarely attends services to come, not just more often in general but on a specific occasion, whether Shabbat, Yom Tov, or weekday; offering to take time to learn Torah with them; not just laying tefillin for them, but teaching them how to put on tefillin; teaching them how to read a Haftarah, perhaps the Torah, or lead a service; giving them an active role in services as a shamash or gabbai. This is aside from a role in lay leadership, such as joining the synagogue board; it is about deepening specifically religious activity.

Not everyone will agree to try to do more, some will agree but not follow through, some will follow through for a while and then participation will tail off, but the more and the wider the Rabbi’s encouragement the greater will be the results. This encouragement has to be personal. I have not seen exhortations from the pulpit or appeals in emails have much effect. Success comes most often from personal invitations made in the context of personal relationships. The greatest success for the Rabbi is when, in the case of an individual, he no longer needs to encourage, because that person now attends and participates because of their own internal enthusiasm and not because of an external intervention. Of course, no longer making specific suggestions should never mean the relationship is allowed to atrophy. Anyone can see when the Rabbi loses interest because their presence is taken for granted, is regarded as “in the bag.”  Instead, what starts out as drawing people in can become a warm, close and settled relationship of fellowship and appreciation. No one should feel looked down upon because they do less, but they should feel celebrated when they do more.

While these three pillars represent an ideal rather than a claim of personal achievement, they are perhaps parts of a vision to which an Inclusive Orthodox Rabbi can aspire and strive. They are a route to combining openness with integrity.

 

 

 

The "I"s Don't Have It: Thoughts for Parashat Toledot

Angel for Shabbat, Parashat Toledot

by Rabbi Marc D. Angel

 

In Biblical Hebrew, the pronoun “I” is expressed in two ways: anokhi and ani. Classical commentaries have explained that anokhi has more emotional weight to it. Ani is simpler, more direct.

Depending on circumstances, Jacob uses both forms, anokhi and ani. But Esau only used anokhi once, when he was famished and traded his birthright for a bowl of lentil stew.  Whereas Jacob was more an anokhi person, Esau was definitely an ani person. Jacob often used anokhi, a word that implies self-reflection, complexity, gravitas. Esau preferred ani, a word that implies egocentricity, simplicity, superficiality.

When Jacob pretended to be Esau in order to win Isaac’s blessing, Jacob identified himself anokhi Esav bekhorekha. When Esau identified himself to Isaac, he said ani binkha bekhorkha. Jacob used anokhi reflecting seriousness and inner conflict. Isaac was surprised by this, since Esau only spoke to him as ani, a straightforward expression of selfhood.

An anokhi person has self-respect but is not self-absorbed. He/she is generally thoughtful, considerate of the feelings of others, interested in society. An ani person is mostly concerned with self, having little consideration for others.

The late Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the Lubavicher Rebbe, once received a letter from someone who wished to see him urgently. The letter went something like this: “Honorable Rebbe: I must see you soon. I am having many difficulties. I am confused. I am struggling with my business. I have problems with my children.  I really need to see you.”  The Rebbe responded to this letter without writing one word!  He returned the letter after circling the first word in each sentence: I.  The person’s problem was his “I”, his self-absorption. An egotistical person is so focused on self as to be unable to relate properly to others. This ani personality undermines healthy relationships with others and leads to various problems.

The Talmudic sage Hillel taught: “If I am not for myself, who is for me? But if I am for myself alone, what am I? …” (Pirkei Avot 1:14). Hillel understood that one must have self-respect and confidence. But he also understood that those “who are for themselves alone” have a personality disorder.  Life is deficient if it is so self-absorbed as to undermine positive relationships with others.

For those seeking a good, happy and righteous life, the “I”’s don’t have it.

 

 

Messianic Hope

 

When we say, “I believe with perfect faith in the coming of the Messiah, and even if he tarries, I will wait for him” —what are waiting for, what are we hoping for?

How does Rambam answer these questions? Let us see. He describes the ultimate end of the messianic process (it is a process for him, not an event) in two places. The first answer is found in the last  paragraph in Mishneh Torah, “Laws of Kings,” xii.4:

 

The Sages and Prophets did not long for the days of the Messiah so that they might exercise dominion over the world, or rule over the nations, or be exalted by the peoples, and not in order to eat and drink and rejoice, but so that they be free to devote themselves to the Torah and its wisdom, with no one to oppress or disturb them, and thus be worthy of life in the world to come, as we explained in “Laws Concerning Repentance.” Then there will be neither famine nor war, neither jealousy nor strife. Good things will be abundant, and delicacies as common as dust. The one preoccupation of the whole world will be only to know the Lord. Hence, they will be very wise, knowing things now unknown and will apprehend knowledge of their Creator to the utmost capacity of the human mind, as it is written: For the land shall be full of the knowledge (de'ah) of the Lord, as the waters cover the sea (Isa. 11:9) [emphasis added, here and below].

 

Who are the “they” referenced here? Early copyists of Mishneh Torah were convinced that Rambam must have meant Jews and changed the text to read “Israel.” This makes no sense for at least two reasons. First, “the preoccupation of the whole world” will be to know God. Second, Rambam nowhere expresses the view or even implies that non-Jews are incapable of knowing God. It is this widespread and deep knowledge of God which explains why “there will be neither famine nor war, neither jealousy nor strife.” In a world governed by intellect “Good things will be abundant, and delicacies as common as dust,” as it could even be today, were the world governed by intellect. Rambam’s messianic vision is universalist and, as we shall see, naturalist.

Prof. Zev Harvey has pointed out that Rambam recapitulates this messianic vision in Guide iii.11 (pp. 353-354 in the new Goodman/Leiberman translation). In that passage, Rambam teaches how to understand the end of Mishneh Torah:

 

These grave evils that human beings inflict on one another, too, out of ambition, passion, opinions and beliefs all reflect privations. Just as a blind man, sightless and unguided, always stumbles, harming himself and others, human sects perpetuate dreadful evils against their fellow humans and themselves, reflecting their ignorance. Had they the insight befitting our human form, as vision befits the eye, all the harm they do to each other and themselves would end. For knowledge of the truth would dissolve hatred and spite and end the crimes of man against man. Thus, the promise The wolf shall dwell with the lamb, and the leopard couch with the kid …the cow graze with the bear…the suckling play [by the viper’s nest] (Isaiah 11:6-8). And the reason is given why such strife, hatred and struggles for power will end – man will truly know God as He truly is: They shall not harm or destroy in all My holy mountain for the earth shall be filled with knowledge of the Lord, as the waters cover the sea (Is. 11:9).

 

In this very short chapter, Rambam elaborates on the promises made in “Kings,” xii.4. The fulfillment of these promises depends not on miracles, not on changes in fundamental human nature, but on truly knowing “God as He truly is.” Both passages end with the same verse from Isaiah.

How ought we to read these two passages –as promises or as challenges? My point in this short essay is to argue that Rambam’s messianic vision is not a promise or a prediction of what will be, but a challenge to act in a fashion that will bring the world closer to the messianic era.

The messianic world is no different from our world, only (much) better: “Let it not enter your mind that in the days of the messiah any aspect of the regular order of nature will be abolished or some innovation will be introduced into the world of nature; rather, the world follows its accustomed course…” (“Laws of Kings,” xii.1).

However, the fulfillment of the three passages cited here depends upon humanity being vastly better than it is now. In Guide iii.32 (p. 438) Rambam emphasizes that God does not use miracles to change human nature. Rambam calls this “a major principle.” Rambam’s reservations about the possibility of truly knowing God (something even Moses failed to accomplish—Guide i.54) are well known. Since after the Messiah comes, “the world follows its accustomed course,” it would appear that Rambam’s description of the messianic world cannot be a promise or a prediction; it is, rather, a challenge to us make our world as close as possible to the messianic world.

For Rambam, the Torah holds out the promise that “knowledge of the truth would dissolve hatred and spite and end the crimes of man against man.” In such a world “ambition, passion, opinions and beliefs” will be dissolved by “knowledge of the truth.” Humans will no longer harm each other or themselves — “strife, hatred and struggles for power will end.” All this will come about through widespread knowledge of God. This is how Rambam himself interpreted the end of the Mishneh Torah in the Guide. Taking the last paragraph of the Mishneh Torah both literally and seriously and interpreting it as he himself interprets it in the Guide, we learn that Rambam anticipated a messianic world in which all human beings will devote themselves to the knowledge of God. We appear to have here a messianic vision, not of utopia (literally, no place), but of reversion to the Garden of Eden before the sin of Adam and Eve. The restorative nature of the messianic world is made clear in the passage with which Rambam opens his discussion of the Messiah in Mishneh Torah (“Laws of Kings, xi.1):

 

King messiah will arise and restore the kingdom of David to its former state and original sovereignty. He will rebuild the sanctuary and gather the dispersed of Israel. All the ancient laws will be reinstituted in his days; sacrifices will again be offered; the sabbatical and jubilee years will again be observed in accordance with the commandments set forth in the Law.

 

Rambam thus opens his account of the messianic era here by emphasizing its restorative character. The messiah will re-establish what once was and thus miracles will not be necessary. The non-miraculous restoration of what once was must be a process, not an event. As such, it is a challenge to those alive at that time to help the process forward.

Rambam’s vision is restorative, not utopian. From this it follows that the messianic era will in principle be not unlike the present world. Hollywood will not be called upon for special effects. Since the messianic era is constituted by the reconstitution of a past golden age, it is possible to find our way forward to what once was in the past (not “Back to the Future” but “Forward to the Past’) without miracles, and nature will therefore continue in its accustomed patterns, and hence the messianic era must be brought about through human effort. Note well: in this text Rambam says, ‘The days of the Messiah refers to the time when sovereignty will return to Israel, and the people of Israel will return to the Land of Israel.’ Nowhere does he say that God will send the Messiah; rather, he implies that it is up to humans to bring the Messiah. From this it follows that the coming of the Messiah is a process, not an event. This passage repeatedly focuses on political freedom and sovereignty. This point is important to emphasize, since many of our contemporaries (mis)read Rambam as teaching that the point of the messianic era is Jewish sovereignty over the (whole) Land of Israel (not to mention dominion over it). For Rambam, the point of the messianic era is knowing God.

Wisdom, apprehension, and knowledge cannot be achieved by war, only by study. The whole world can become preoccupied with the knowledge of the Lord only if war is replaced by education. To the extent that it is rational for ends to determine means, then the only way to bring about the fulfilment of the messianic redemption, at least as it is understood by Rambam, is to make the study of true Torah (which includes ma’aseh bereshit, physics, and ma’aseh merkavah, metaphysics) our aim, and not domination of one group by another. 

Was Rambam actually enough of an optimist to anticipate a messianic return to an Edenic humanity without miracles? This seems to be a large mouthful—in such a reality, the world would not continue in its accustomed way, human nature as we know it would be replaced by an improved version, and the Torah of Moses would be replaced by the Torah of Abraham.

In order properly to comprehend Rambam’s view of future history, as it were, it will be useful to examine his understanding of past history. James Diamond leads the way by citing Aviezer Ravitzky to the effect that the key to Rambam’s messianic vision "is to be found precisely in Rambam’s allegorical interpretation of the story of the Garden of Eden in the opening chapters of the Guide ... the opening of human history is united with its final perfection ... the universal redemption of the human race ... refers in fact to man's return to his original stature represented by the human archetype." For Rambam, the Eden story teaches values, not history. He presents the story of Adam, Eve, the serpent, and the Garden of Eden in Guide i.1-2 and ii.30, not as an account of what actually happened, but as an explanation of the human condition as it is and as it will be. Torah does not describe past history and apparently does not describe future history. Rambam’s account of the messianic future is not an account of what will happen; rather it is an account of a future which we should aim for, even if it is not clear that we will ever actually arrive at it. In terms I learned from my teacher Steven Schwarzchild it is regulative, not predictive. In other words, Rambam’s vision of the messianic era is not a prediction but an ideal to regulate our behavior in the here and now—not a promise, but a challenge.

Continuing in a Schwarzschildian mode, Kenneth Seeskin (like me, a student, friend, and admirer of Schwarschild) commented (personal communication): “In general, it might be pointed out that according to Rambam, human nature will not change during the Days of the Messiah so that the laws of the Torah will still be binding.Yes, Schwarzschild was optimistic to the extent that he thought a messianic era was not only possible but one day would actually arrive. But, no, he was not so optimistic as to think that human beings would be able to dispense with holidays and rituals.”

What then can we learn from “Laws of Kings,” xii.4 and Guide iii.11 if we cannot learn future history? We can learn, as Kenneth Seeskin teaches, that there is much reason for hope. In Rambam’s view the point of the messianic era is to bring the Torah lekhol ba’ei olam, to all human beings. This messianic vision offers us a goal at which to aim, an ideal by which to regulate our behavior. That goal is the realization of the opening chapters of the Bible: all human beings are created in the image of God and should therefore be treated, not only as means, but as ends, also

Rambam’s naturalism means that this goal can in principle be achieved by human beings, without divine intervention, miraculous or otherwise. Kant insisted that ought implies can: if I ought to do something, I must be able to do it. Steven Schwarzschild insisted on a Jewish corollary to that Kantian teaching: If I can achieve some worthwhile goal, then I am obligated to try to achieve it. Getting ever closer to a messianic world is surely a worthwhile goal. Actually, reaching that goal may not be possible, but getting ever closer is. Since we can do it, we should make every effort to make the world a place in which all human beings are treated as creatures made in the image of God. Rambam, in effect anticipating Hermann Cohen, and Schwarzschild, following Cohen, teaches that we ought to devote ourselves to the project of creating a messiah-worthy world.

Hermann Cohen and, following him, Yeshayahu Leibowitz, would say that Rambam did not really expect this to happen, that we may come ever closer to the messianic era, but will never actually reach it.  That may or may not have been Rambam’s actual position; I do not really have a settled opinion on the subject. What is crucial to understand is that—whether actually achievable, or an ever-receding while paradoxically ever-closer dream—Rambam’s messianic vision is one of ultimate universal peace and enlightenment. This is a vision which will be realized only if human beings do not wait for God to do it but bring it about themselves.

In sum, there is something important that Maimonidean messianic universalism and naturalism teaches us: hope. We can hope for (and work towards) a world in which different nations and cultures can value their own contributions to the human mosaic without diminishing the value of others—without wholly otherizing the other. If we can hope, we need not despair: the human condition is not necessarily tragic.

 

For Further Reading

 

Diamond, James. Maimonides and the Shaping of the Jewish Canon (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2014).

Kellner, Menachem and David Gillis. Maimonides the Universalist: The Ethical Horizons of the Mishneh Torah (London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 2020).

Kellner, Menachem. "And the Crooked Shall be Made Straight: Twisted Messianic Visions – A Maimonidean Corrective," Michael Morgan and Steven Weitzman (eds.), Rethinking the Messianic Idea: New Perspectives on Jewish Messianism (Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2014): 108-140.

Kellner, Menachem. "Farteitcht un Farbessert (On 'Correcting' Maimonides)," Me'orot [=Edah Journal] 6.2 (2007). (http://library.yctorah.org/files/2016/07/Kellner-on-Rambam-FINAL.pdf).

Kellner, Menachem. "Rambam’s True Religion – for Jews, or All Humanity?" Me'orot  [=Edah Journal] 7.1 (2008) (https://library.yctorah.org/files/2016/07/Kellner-III-with-Rapoport-response-revision6.pdf).

Kellner, Menachem. "The Other,” in Paul Franks and Yitzchak Melamed (eds.), Oxford Handbook of Jewish Philosophy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2026), 751–772.

Klein-Braslavy, Sara. “Bible Commentary,” in K. Seeskin (ed.) Cambridge Companion to Maimonides  (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press: 2005), 245–273.

Maimonides, Moses. Guide to the Perplexed, translated by Lenn Evan Goodman and Phillip Lieberman (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2025).

Schwarzschild, Steven S. “The Messianic Doctrine in Contemporary Jewish Thought,” in Abraham Milgram (ed.), Great Jewish Ideas (Washington, DC: Bnai Brith, 1964), 231-259, 339-341. 

Seeskin, Kenneth, Jewish Messianic Thoughts in an Age of Despair (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2012).

Seeskin, Kenneth. "Maimonides and Hermann Cohen on Messianism," Maimonidean Studies 5 (2008): 375–392.

New Book review of Rabbi Hayyim Angel's Megillot book

Ben Rothke published an excellent review of Rabbi Hayyim Angel's book, The Heart of the Five Megillot.

 

Jewish Press, September 24, 2026

https://jewishpress.com/the-five-megillot-beyond-easy-answers/

 

Title: The Heart of the Five Megillot: Tradition, Complexity, and Meaning

By: Rabbi Hayyim Angel

(158 pages)

The Five Megillot are read annually. One could easily mistake these books for being germane only to the time of year in which they are read. In The Heart of the Five Megillot: Tradition, Complexity, and Meaning, Rabbi Hayyim Angel quickly puts that erroneous notion to rest.

The Five Megillot – Song of Songs, Ruth, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, and Esther – are among the more challenging books of Tanach. Rabbi Angel demonstrates that they are not merely timeless literary and religious classics, but texts that continue to speak powerfully throughout the year. Their themes – love, loyalty, identity, suffering, mortality, meaning, evil, and Divine Providence – are as relevant today as they were when these works were first composed.

Although many of the essays in this volume have appeared previously, readers encountering them for the first time will find Angel to be a writer of considerable depth, sophistication, and clarity. More importantly, he does not treat these Biblical books simply as repositories of inspirational lessons. He takes their literary and theological complexity seriously. That is one of the book’s greatest strengths – rather than forcing difficult passages into convenient answers, Angel allows the texts to challenge the reader.

Song of Songs provides perhaps the clearest example. On its surface, it is intensely sensual love poetry. Yet Rabbi Akiva famously described it as “Holy of Holies,” recognizing a profound theological dimension beneath its apparent surface meaning. Angel explores the longstanding difficulty of determining how the book should be understood. Is it literal love poetry? Figurative language? An allegory of the relationship between G-d and Israel? Rather than dismissing the tension, Angel uses it as an opportunity to explore the text’s remarkable interpretive richness.

Ruth presents a different set of challenges. Angel examines its stories of loyalty, kindness, identity, conversion, acceptance, and belonging, showing how much lies beneath its deceptively simple narrative. His literary approach draws attention to word choice, repetition, characterization, and narrative structure, revealing layers of meaning that can easily be overlooked on a straightforward reading.

He applies the same approach to the remaining three Megillot. In Lamentations, he confronts the agonizing question of how to relate to a G-d who has seemingly abandoned His people. Ecclesiastes wrestles with some of the most fundamental questions of human existence: What is the meaning of life? What ultimately remains after the pursuit of wealth, achievement, and physical pleasure? And in Esther, Angel examines a book in which G-d is never explicitly mentioned, yet Divine Providence can be discerned even when He appears to be absent.

Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of the book is Angel’s ability to bring together two approaches that are sometimes portrayed as incompatible: traditional Jewish interpretation and modern literary scholarship. Rather than viewing them as competing methodologies, he demonstrates how they can complement one another and produce a deeper understanding of the Biblical text. The result is an approach that allows readers to benefit from contemporary scholarship without sacrificing traditional Jewish perspectives or religious integrity.

The word “Complexity” in the subtitle is particularly appropriate. One of the dangers of religious commentary is the temptation to make Biblical texts seem simpler than they really are. A difficult passage becomes a straightforward moral lesson; an ambiguity becomes a certainty; a profound theological problem becomes little more than a sermon. Angel generally resists these temptations.

Indeed, one of the book’s most important insights is that ambiguity is not necessarily a flaw in a Biblical text. Sometimes ambiguity is precisely what gives a work its enduring power. Esther’s hidden G-d, Ecclesiastes’ apparent pessimism, Lamentations’ confrontation with suffering, Ruth’s complicated questions of identity and belonging, and Song of Songs’ blending of human and Divine love all become richer when we allow the texts to remain complicated rather than insisting on easy resolutions.

This leads to what is perhaps the most important lesson of the book: The purpose of studying Tanach is not always to eliminate questions. Sometimes it is to learn how to ask better questions. That is an especially valuable lesson in an age in which complex religious and literary texts are often reduced to easily digestible messages.

Despite Angel’s considerable scholarly expertise, the essays are accessible to readers who are not specialists in academic Bible scholarship. He succeeds in maintaining intellectual rigor without making the material unnecessarily difficult or inaccessible.

The Heart of the Five Megillot is ultimately a reminder that these five books deserve to be read not merely as holiday texts or sources of familiar religious lessons, but as works of extraordinary literary, intellectual, and theological sophistication. Rabbi Hayyim Angel brings that complexity back into focus. The result is a thoughtful and illuminating collection that encourages readers not only to understand the Five Megillot more deeply, but to appreciate why these ancient texts continue to speak so powerfully to modern readers.

 

The Heart of the Five Megillot, as well as The Heart of Joshua, are available in paperback or kindle format at amazon.com. Check them out here:

https://www.amazon.com/Heart-Five-Megillot-Tradition-Complexity/dp/B0H7VZKZ6M/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3JS35QXKO7802&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.Nn0H3HwjLpcQTxcr9D…

https://www.amazon.com/Heart-Joshua-Wilderness-Covenant-Tanakh/dp/B0HJD2VY4L/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3FDF2FWQHAM9Q&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.VjfLo08YgQcBxaD7xEB…

 

Does God Attend Daily Minyan?

 

The famous Hasidic Kotzker Rebbe commented that God comes where God is invited.  In principle, God should be invited to every daily minyan in every synagogue throughout the world. Each worshiper should feel the presence of God when praying. The services should be conducted with love, devotion, piety…with a genuine desire to experience the Divine. 

Very fortunate are those who attend daily minyan and who indeed invite God’s presence…and feel God’s presence. The spiritual uplift of sincere prayer is of inestimable value.

Regrettably, the daily minyan experience isn’t always like this ideal model. Prayers are often recited quickly, by rote, without evoking much religious emotion.  In some synagogues, even the rabbis don’t attend daily services regularly; and when they do show up, it’s usually late. And then rather than immerse in prayers, they are busy chatting or joking with congregants.

Some attend daily minyan because that’s what Jews are supposed to do. It’s part of their daily routine and is important to them. They are pleased to participate in services, chat with fellow congregants, maybe even have some refreshments after prayers. But whether God is at the center of their concern is a moot point. For many, they sincerely pray to God. For others, God isn’t even on their minds!

Some years ago, my dear and respected friend, Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo, wrote an article about the "relocation" of God. Here is an excerpt from that article.

"Synagogues – whether Orthodox, Conservative or Reform – are no longer His primary residence. Surely some of the worshippers are pious people who try to communicate with their Creator, but overall, the majority of these places have become religiously sterile and spiritually empty. So God is moving to unconventional minyanim and places such as Israeli cafes, debating clubs, community centers, unaffiliated religious gatherings, and atypical batei midrash. The reason is obvious. In some of those places people are actually looking for Him. And that is what He loves; not those who have already found Him and take Him for granted."

While I believe Rabbi Cardozo’s contention is over-stated, it contains deep truth. God has not abandoned synagogues that aspire to holiness, that raise our spirits and nourish our souls. God has not given up on the many pious Jews who sincerely pray in their daily minyanim. But Rabbi Cardozo touches on a serious dilemma…where synagogues don’t seem to be inviting God’s presence, don’t convey a sense of religious yearning and solemnity. If God isn’t experienced in the daily minyan, it means God isn’t really invited. And if God isn’t invited, daily minyan loses its raison d’etre.

The daily minyan, for many, is a spiritual anchor of their lives. They pray quietly, meditatively. They avoid chatter or frivolity in the sanctuary. They conduct themselves as though they are in the presence of God. Ashrei Yoshevei Veitekha…happy are those who dwell in Your house…a house where You are not only invited but are the Host.

Survival, Sovereignty, and the Liberty of the Jewish People

 

There is a comforting tendency in contemporary discussions of Jewish history to speak of survival almost as though survival itself constituted victory.

I cannot accept that formulation. For me, Jewish and Zionist identity is neither an abstraction nor merely a religious affiliation detachable from history. It is the inheritance of a people whose collective memory has been shaped by exile and return, persecution and creativity, political vulnerability and national renewal—and, above all, by an extraordinary determination not to disappear.

This understanding is intensely personal. Almost my entire family was murdered because they were Jews. The overwhelming majority of the Jewish community from which I come was segregated, dispossessed, deported, and exterminated during the German occupation of the Netherlands. Centuries before that catastrophe, my Sephardic ancestors left the magnificent Iberian Peninsula because remaining openly Jewish had become impossible.

These are not remote episodes in a history book. They form part of the consciousness through which I understand Jewish identity. I speak as a native Dutchman who later became an American citizen; as a Jew by faith, culture, history, memory, and peoplehood; and politically as what has become an increasingly rare creature: an old-fashioned General Zionist.

 

The Lost Center of Zionism

 

General Zionism once occupied an important position within the Zionist movement. Historically, it described those Zionists who belonged neither to the socialist-Labor camp nor to the religious parties. Over time important elements of General Zionism became associated with European liberalism, private enterprise, a substantial middle class, constitutional government, civic responsibility, and Jewish national self-determination. That political world has largely vanished.

 

The old disagreements among General Zionists, Labor Zionists, Revisionists, religious Zionists, and other movements were never merely quarrels among party organizations. They reflected fundamentally different conceptions of the society Zionism ought to create once Jews again possessed political sovereignty.

 

What should a Jewish state be?

 

Was Jewish sovereignty merely intended to provide Jews with military and political power after centuries of defenselessness? Or was sovereignty supposed to create something greater: a society in which Jewish national independence existed together with liberty, constitutional restraint, human dignity, freedom of conscience, and civic responsibility?

For me, the latter was always implicit in the Zionist project. Zionism was not meant simply to exchange Jewish powerlessness for Jewish power. Its purpose was the restoration of Jewish political agency: the ability of the Jewish people to take responsibility for their own security, culture, institutions, and future.

But political agency carries obligations as well as rights. When corruption, ideological absolutism, political polarization, or irresponsible leadership weakens democratic institutions, the danger to a nation does not arise exclusively from external enemies. A sovereign people must possess sufficient confidence to examine itself.

Jewish history teaches us what can happen when others possess unlimited power over Jews. Jewish sovereignty should also teach us why unlimited power is dangerous in anyone’s hands. Survival Is Not Victory

The Jewish people survived Babylonian conquest and exile.

We survived Rome. We survived expulsions, forced conversions, massacres, ghettos, inquisitions, pogroms, and centuries in which Jewish existence often depended upon the goodwill of rulers whose protection could vanish overnight.

Then came the destruction of European Jewry. Six million Jews were murdered. Ancient communities disappeared. Families vanished. Languages, schools, synagogues, libraries, traditions, institutions, and entire Jewish civilizations were destroyed.

Three years after the liberation of Auschwitz, the State of Israel proclaimed its independence. That restoration of Jewish sovereignty was among the most consequential events in modern Jewish history.

But sovereignty does not retroactively transform catastrophe into victory. The murdered did not “win” because descendants or survivors lived to establish a state.

That distinction matters. Survival means that the murderers failed to extinguish the Jewish people. It means that after destruction someone remained to say Kaddish.

Someone remained to teach a child the Shemang. Someone reopened a synagogue. Someone wrote Hebrew poetry. Someone argued about Jewish politics. Someone built another Jewish home. Someone raised the flag of a sovereign Jewish state. That is an extraordinary historical achievement.

But it came at an almost incomprehensible human cost. Our great achievement is therefore not that history could not wound us.

History wounded us terribly.

Our achievement is that it could not erase us. Empires that ruled us disappeared. Governments that expelled us fell. Movements that sought to convert us failed. Regimes that attempted to annihilate us were eventually consigned to history.

And still there are Jews. Still Hebrew is spoken. Still Torah is studied. Still our melodies are sung.

Still Jewish children are born. Still Jerusalem occupies its incomparable place in Jewish and civilized consciousness.

And today there exists a sovereign State of Israel in which Jews possess something denied to generations before us: the political capacity to participate directly in determining their national future.

That is not triumphalism. It is continuity. 

 

The Dutch Lesson: Liberty of Conscience

Yet there is another element of my identity that is equally important to understanding my Zionism. I remain profoundly Dutch.

 

When I think about political liberty, I think not only about Herzl, Pinsker, Jabotinsky, Weizmann, Ben-Gurion, or the Zionist Congresses. I also think of William the Silent and of the long, imperfect struggle in the Netherlands against religious coercion.

The Pacification of Ghent of 1576 arose from the revolt against Spanish authority and included an end to religious persecution as part of an effort to reunite deeply divided provinces. It did not create modern religious liberty, and its compromises quickly proved fragile. Nevertheless, it formed part of William of Orange’s effort to achieve a measure of religious peace in a society torn apart by confessional conflict. 

The Union of Utrecht of 1579 went further in establishing what became one of the foundational political arrangements of the northern Netherlands. It expressly provided that no person should be persecuted on account of religion, even while the individual provinces retained considerable authority over public worship. It was therefore not yet the American First Amendment, nor was it a modern separation of church and state. But it helped establish a principle of immense historical significance: the state should not hunt a person into the privacy of his conscience.

That distinction matters. The early Dutch Republic did not abolish religious privilege. Public worship was regulated, religious minorities remained subject to restrictions, and full civic equality was far from complete. Yet something revolutionary had begun.

The violent principle that political authority must impose a single religious truth upon every citizen gradually yielded to a more pragmatic conception of society: people of different convictions could inhabit the same political community without requiring one another’s theological submission.

For European civilization, this was no small achievement. It created space in which Jews, Protestants of different denominations, Catholics, freethinkers, merchants, scholars, refugees, and dissenters could coexist—sometimes uneasily, often imperfectly, but with a degree of freedom extraordinary for its time. That environment mattered enormously to Sephardic Jews.  It helped make my home city Amsterdam one of the great centers of Jewish intellectual, commercial, and religious life. The lesson was profound: A state becomes stronger, not weaker, when it ceases attempting to govern the human conscience.

 

Zionism and Constitutional Liberty

This brings me to an unresolved question at the heart of the Zionist enterprise.

 

The Zionist movement created institutions, mobilized Jewish communities across continents, promoted settlement, developed political diplomacy, fostered Hebrew culture, and laid much of the organizational groundwork from which Jewish sovereignty emerged. The World Zionist Organization itself was founded at the First Zionist Congress in Basel in 1897, with the goal of securing a recognized Jewish home in Eretz Yisrael.

Yet when Israel achieved independence in 1948, the new state did not ultimately adopt the comprehensive written constitution originally contemplated by its founders.

Israel today possesses Basic Laws based upon Ottoman and British jurisprudence rather than a single codified constitutional document. The Knesset itself acknowledges that the state has no comprehensive constitution and that disputes about Israel’s identity as both Jewish and democratic have contributed to the continuing constitutional debate. That unfinished constitutional project should concern Zionists.

The Declaration of Independence spoke in unmistakably liberal terms. It envisioned a state founded upon freedom, justice, and peace, and promised equality of social and political rights irrespective of religion, race, or sex, together with freedom of religion and conscience. Those principles were not foreign decorations attached to Zionism.

They belong at its center.

Indeed, the World Zionist Organization’s own current constitution describes Zionism as adhering to justice, equality, and democracy and as rejecting discrimination on grounds including origin, nationality, race, gender, and sexual orientation.

The question, therefore, is not whether liberty is somehow incompatible with Zionism. The more difficult question is whether Zionist institutions and the State of Israel are sufficiently determined to defend liberty when doing so becomes politically inconvenient.

 

Freedom of Speech Is Not a Luxury

 

Freedom of speech is especially important in a society whose citizens carry radically different memories, religious convictions, political philosophies, and understandings of national identity.

A free society does not protect speech because every opinion is wise. It protects speech because no government, political faction, religious establishment, or ideological movement can safely be entrusted with determining which opinions may be expressed.

 

Zionism itself could hardly have developed without intellectual dissent. Herzl challenged accepted assumptions about Jewish emancipation. Ahad Ha’am challenged political Zionism. Religious Zionists challenged secular Zionists. Revisionists challenged Labor. General Zionists challenged both socialist collectivism and religious political authority.

Israeli democracy has always contained arguments of extraordinary intensity precisely because Jewish sovereignty returned political disagreement to the Jewish people. That disagreement is not evidence of national weakness. Properly protected, it is evidence of political maturity.

The moment criticism of government becomes confused with treason, or disagreement with religious authority becomes confused with hostility to Judaism, liberty is already in danger.

Freedom of Religion Means Freedom From Religious Coercion  The same principle applies to religion.

A Jewish state has every right to express Jewish history, Hebrew civilization, the Jewish calendar, Jewish national memory, and the relationship of the Jewish people to Eretz Yisrael. But the Jewish character of a state cannot depend upon compelling belief. Faith imposed through political power ceases to be faith and becomes coercion.

Freedom of religion necessarily includes several liberties simultaneously: the freedom to believe, the freedom to practice, the freedom to change one’s degree of observance, the freedom to belong to a different religious tradition, and the freedom not to believe at all. Those liberties protect religious Jews as much as secular Jews. They protect the Orthodox Jew from a hostile secular majority. They protect the secular Jew from rabbinic coercion.

They protect Sephardim whose religious traditions differ from Ashkenazi establishments. They protect Reform and Conservative Jews. They protect Christians, Muslims, Druze, Baháʼís, and others. And they protect the individual human conscience.

A government powerful enough to impose somebody else’s religion upon you today is powerful enough to suppress your religion tomorrow.

Jewish history should make us particularly sensitive to that danger. 

 

The Seduction of Religious Extremism

 

Religious extremism becomes dangerous when theological certainty acquires political power.

 

This danger is not unique to Judaism, Christianity, or Islam.

It is a danger inherent whenever human beings become convinced that disagreement with them constitutes rebellion against God.

Once political opponents cease being fellow citizens and become heretics, traitors, infidels, apostates, or enemies of divine purpose, ordinary democratic compromise becomes morally suspect.

From there, persecution becomes dangerously easy to justify.

Jewish civilization knows the consequences of such thinking because Jews have repeatedly been its victims.

We therefore carry a particular responsibility not to reproduce the logic that persecuted us. No rabbi, priest, imam, minister, politician, or ideological movement should possess authority over another person’s conscience. No government should determine which interpretation of God every citizen must accept. And no political majority should imagine that electoral victory gives it ownership over the spiritual life of minorities.

 

The Jewish State Must Not Fear Liberty

 

Some believe that more religious coercion makes Israel more Jewish.

I believe Jewish history suggests precisely the opposite question should be asked: What kind of Jewish society requires coercion to remain Jewish?

A civilization confident in itself does not fear freedom. Judaism survived Babylon, Rome, Christendom, Islam, the Inquisition, emancipation, secularism, communism, fascism, assimilation, and modernity. It does not require a policeman standing behind the synagogue door. Nor should secular Israelis fear Judaism.

The Bible, rabbinic civilization, Sephardic philosophy, Jewish law, Hebrew language, liturgy, poetry, historical memory, and the experience of exile constitute a civilizational inheritance vastly larger than any contemporary political party or religious institution.

A genuinely Jewish and democratic state ought therefore to protect both Jewish civilization and personal liberty. The two need not be enemies.

 

From Survival to Responsibility

 

The Jewish people have accomplished something remarkable.

We survived.

But after 1948, survival alone could no longer be the complete Zionist program.

A sovereign people must ask not merely whether its state exists, but what kind of state it wishes to become.

That is the transition from survival to responsibility.

Jewish history imposes upon us an obligation to defend Jews against persecution.

But that same history ought to make us defenders of the persecuted.

Jewish history teaches us the danger of statelessness.

But it should also teach us the danger of unrestricted state power.

Jewish history teaches us to cherish our religion.

But it should therefore also teach us that religion is most precious when freely embraced rather than politically imposed.

And Jewish history teaches us the value of having a national voice.

It should therefore make us reluctant to silence the voices of others.

The Netherlands of William the Silent did not instantly create modern liberal democracy. Neither did the American Revolution, the French Revolution, or any other historical transformation produce perfect liberty overnight.

Political liberty developed slowly, through struggle, contradiction, compromise, and repeated correction.

Israel’s constitutional journey remains similarly unfinished.

Perhaps that unfinished work constitutes one of the most important Zionist tasks of our generation.

We must preserve the Jewish state.

But we must also preserve the kind of liberty that makes a Jewish state worth preserving.

We must defend Israel against those who seek its destruction.

 

But we must equally defend its democratic institutions against those—whether religious or secular, right or left—who would subordinate individual conscience to ideological power.

And we must remember that Jewish sovereignty was not restored merely so that Jews could survive behind stronger walls.

It was restored so that after centuries of living at the mercy of others, the Jewish people could build a society worthy of its history.

Am Yisrael does not exist because history was kind to us.

We exist because generation after generation Jews chose to remain Jews.

The challenge of sovereignty is greater still:

to remain Jewish without becoming intolerant;

to remain strong without worshipping power;

to remain faithful without coercing faith;

to remain national without denying human dignity;

and to defend the State of Israel without surrendering the freedoms that give democratic sovereignty its moral meaning.

Survival brought us here.

Liberty, responsibility, and constitutional restraint must help determine what we become.

I also changed the historical formulation about the Dutch Republic slightly. The Pacification of Ghent and Union of Utrecht were major milestones toward liberty of conscience, but not modern church–state separation; Article 13 of the Union allowed considerable provincial control over public religious practice while establishing that individuals should not be persecuted for their religion. That nuance actually strengthens your comparison with Israel because it shows constitutional liberty developing gradually rather than appearing fully formed. 

Let me finish with the motto of my native country:

Je maintiendrai!

(I shall maintain)

Upcoming Classes with Rabbi Hayyim Angel

With the holidays coming toward an end, Rabbi Hayyim Angel will be resuming his classes, many of which are available to members of the Institute.

On Mondays October 12, 19, and 26, from 1:15-2:15 pm Eastern, Rabbi Hayyim Angel will give the next installments of his series over Zoom on the history of Biblical Interpretation (Rabbi Yitzhak Abarbanel, Rabbi Ovadiah Sforno, and the 16th-19th century commentators). It is hosted by Lamdeinu, and registration is required. 

https://www.lamdeinu.org/donations/monday-the-parshanim-their-methods-and-contributions/

On Tuesday, October 13, from 8:00-9:00 pm Eastern, Rabbi Hayyim Angel will give a class on the Tower of Babel: Classical interpretation and the Ancient Near East. It is over Zoom and is hosted by The Ben Porat Yeshiva Day School in Paramus, NJ. Free and open to the public. Here is the link:

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83206895741

Beginning Monday, October 19, from 12:15-1:00 pm Eastern, Rabbi Hayyim Angel will resume teaching at the Beit Midrash of Teaneck. Classes are free live at the Jewish Center of Teaneck (70 Sterling Place, Teaneck NJ). They are also available over Zoom. Classes meet on Mondays and Wednesdays at that time, and we are in the middle of the Book of Exodus/Shemot.

For more information on schedule and how to sign up for Zoom, please contact Mrs. Leah Feldman:

[email protected]

Looking forward to learning with you!

 

The Unwritten Layer: Women’s Wisdom and the Future of Jewish Hope

 

 

The Jewish story we tell ourselves is not complete. Essential parts of it have been preserved outside the written canon, within the rhythms of life itself, and especially in the voices of women. For the Jewish story to continue, it must also include what has been preserved beyond texts, the wisdom carried through women’s tradition.

In his influential work The Jewish Way, Rabbi Professor Irving Yitzhak Greenberg offers a profound and compelling interpretation of Jewish time in the modern era. His writing, which integrates theological depth, historical sensitivity, and a deep commitment to the Jewish future, has helped shape contemporary Jewish thought in the aftermath of the Holocaust and the founding of the State of Israel.

Alongside his contribution, the work and presence of Blu Greenberg have also deeply influenced me. Their home in Riverdale was, for me, a generous space of encounter, conversation, and inspiration, where I was invited to present my work on women’s prayer.

It was precisely this deep appreciation that I found myself pausing at the margins of his book, in an appendix titled “Outside the Historical Path.” There, among what were described as “minor holidays,” appeared Rosh Hodesh.

Perhaps it is within such a broad framework that we are invited to ask not only what is included in the story, but also what has remained outside it, and what can now be brought back. In a moment of fracture within Jewish life, this question is not only historical, but existential.

 

Rosh Hodesh: Not at the Margins, but at the Center

 

Rosh Hodesh is far more than a date on the calendar. It marks renewal, a new beginning, a moment of looking forward. In Jewish tradition, it has long been associated with women, with the waxing and waning moon, with cycles, with quiet wisdom, with hope, and with the ability to begin again.

For me, for the women in my family, and for many women across generations, Rosh Hodesh was never marginal. It was never an appendix. It was part of the path itself.

My grandmother, Hannah Mashiach of blessed memory, born in 1900 in Balkh, Afghanistan, who immigrated to Jerusalem in the early twentieth century, carried with her a living world of tradition. In Jerusalem’s Bukharan Quarter, a vibrant communal space filled with prayer, faith, and shared life, embodied a tradition that was both simple and profound.

She knew prayers by heart, like many women of her generation. She would often say, in her simple wisdom:
“We must learn how to live together.”

Each Rosh Hodesh, she dressed in festive clothes, lit a candle, refrained from work, and joined other women in prayer.

Across Jewish communities, similar practices emerged. Women refrained from certain forms of labor, gathered, prayed, and created spaces for reflection. In Ashkenazi communities, the eve of Rosh Hodesh was sometimes called Yom Kippur Katan, while in Sephardi and Middle Eastern communities it was known as Mishmeret Rosh Hodesh.

Despite geographical distance, a shared pattern emerges women, across cultures, preserved a distinct time for reflection, connection, and hope. And yet, despite its centrality in women’s lives, this world is largely absent from the written Jewish narrative.

 

A Partial Story

 

When I encountered descriptions of Rosh Hodesh as a “rediscovery” in 1970s America within feminist circles, I welcomed the awakening. Yet I also felt a deep dissonance. For many women, Rosh Hodesh was never rediscovered. It had never disappeared.

When I later asked Greenberg how such a living tradition could be placed “outside the historical path,” he responded candidly:
“I am an American Ashkenazi Jew. That is the world from which I write.”

This is not a mistake, but a perspective. Yet perspectives shape reality.

The Jewish story, even when expansive and thoughtful, is written within the limits of experience, language, and memory. Not exclusion, but human boundaries.

And so, the question remains: What other voices have remained outside the story we tell ourselves?

 

 The Missing Layer

 

Jewish tradition carefully preserves the written canon. Yet alongside it exists another world, rich and expansive, a world of women’s prayers, rituals, customs, and lived practices.

We have three daughters and a son. Only with our youngest did we celebrate a Zeved HaBat (celebration of the birth of a daughter), after I discovered an ancient text from Italian Jewish tradition. During the ceremony, my father-in-law, David Lavie of blessed memory, stood and said, “We also have a prayer for the birth of a daughter.” In an old family siddur from Tripoli, we found it.

“Why didn’t you tell us?” I asked.
“You didn’t ask,” he replied.

This is how women’s Jewish knowledge often appears: not lost, but unasked.

This knowledge has often been labeled “folklore,” marginal or secondary. But in truth, it is a complete system of meaning, resilience, and hope, born out of life itself. And it does not belong to women alone. It is a resource for the Jewish people.

 

Not a New Creation, but a Living Return

 

In recent years, a quiet yet clear movement has emerged. Women are returning to these spaces, creating circles, rituals, and practices.
This is not invention; it is return. Not imitation, but awakening. Not nostalgia, but a living movement from past to future. It is not only a response to crisis, but an awakening already unfolding. This return does not seek to import meaning from outside, but to uncover what has long existed within Jewish life itself.

 

A Crisis Searching for Language

 

We are living through a profound crisis of Jewish identity. Rising antisemitism, internal divisions, and exhaustion from ongoing struggles are accompanied by a deep search for meaning and belonging. Many are no longer asking only, “What obligates me as a Jew?” but “What does being Jewish mean to me?”

The answer may not lie only in expanding existing knowledge, but in restoring layers of wisdom that have been preserved differently.

 

From Fracture, Hope Emerges

 

This was the first Passover after October 7.

A festival of freedom, while hostages were still in captivity and many were once again called to reserve duty. Many told me they could not read the Haggadah this year. How can one speak of freedom when reality feels so distant from the words?

I found myself returning to the same question: what did Jewish women do in times of rupture, and how can this wisdom be brought into the present moment? I found testimonies of women in labor camps who refused to give up the Seder. They held it in their imagination, imagining matzah and charoset, lighting candles, reciting Kiddush, and singing “Next year in Jerusalem.” Others reconstructed rituals and recipes even under the harshest conditions.

I brought texts from times of crisis, from the Inquisition and beyond. I read from a Haggadah I compiled, Od Nachzor HaBayta (We Will Return Home), printed copies, and distributed them.

Among the pages, I shared a tiny Haggadah, six lines long, written in Auschwitz on toilet paper, the size of a matchbox, by Toby Trackeltaub of Munkatch:

 

Pesach, 5705, Auschwitz

Toby Trackeltaub

 

We long to celebrate, but we cannot.
We yearn to believe, and that is the one thing we still possess, the one thing they cannot take from us: memory.
Only this can give us hope for a better and more beautiful future, a future we hold in our minds without lowering our heads.

And just as God redeemed our ancestors from Egypt,
so too will He save us from our bitter bondage
and restore us to the land of our ancestors.

 

These words opened hearts.

This is what hope looks like in Jewish tradition: not a simple promise, but an act.

Not an escape from reality, but a refusal to surrender meaning within it. Perhaps it is precisely in such moments that we understand how the knowledge preserved in lived experience, and especially by women, is not marginal at all, but a living source of resilience and continuity.

 

A Source of Hope

 

Restoring women’s Jewish knowledge to the center is not only a correction of the past, but a possibility for the future. It expands our language at a moment when it is narrowing.

This knowledge offers another path, not to erase differences, but to connect across them.

 For me, this is not only a scholarly question. It is a life mission. Over the years, in encounters with women and men in Israel and across Jewish communities worldwide, I have repeatedly seen how knowledge preserved by women, in prayers, customs, and memory, carries a quiet yet persistent wisdom, one that sustains life even in times of uncertainty.

It has the capacity to repair, not as theory, but as a way of life: to heal fractures of identity, to reconnect individuals to tradition, and to bridge distances between people.

From this understanding, the Women’s Prayer Project (TfilatNashim.com) emerged, a cultural-spiritual initiative that brings women’s voices back into the center of Jewish life.

It is a living space of Jewish identity, where ancient prayers, customs, and stories rooted in Jewish life meet contemporary experience, offering tools for leadership, resilience, and meaning. Not nostalgia, but future.

This is not only a story to be told, but a voice to be encountered. Those who wish to listen more closely are invited to enter this living space, where these voices continue to speak, be shared, and be renewed.

The Jewish story will not be written only through what is preserved in books, but through the voices we choose to restore, and the ones we choose to hear.