National Scholar Updates

Thoughts for Thanksgiving 2026

Thoughts for Thanksgiving 2026

By Rabbi Marc D. Angel

Israel is in an uneasy cease-fire with Hamas and under constant threat of terrorism and possible war with Iran. Anti-Jewish words and deeds have skyrocketed throughout the world. In the United States, we witness anti-Israel and anti-Semitic hatred on the streets, on college campuses, and in the media.

Yes, there are many things that concern us. The “American Dream” isn’t as peaceful and optimistic as it was in past years. 

But we are thankful for America. We are thankful to the Almighty for the many blessings showered upon our country.

We are thankful that the nation’s President has stood with Israel and the Jewish People at this time of crisis. We are grateful for the support of Israel and American Jewry by the American Congress and many political leaders on all levels of government. We are grateful for the many millions of Americans who stand with Israel and the Jewish People.

For Jews, as for so many others, America has been—and continues to be—a land of opportunity and freedom. The ideas and ideals of America continue to inspire and to give hope. Without ignoring or belittling the many problems facing the country, we must be grateful for its positive values, its commitment to democracy, and its strong opposition to tyrannical nations.

We pray that those who hate Israel and the Jewish People will overcome their hatred…and reach out sincerely for peaceful co-existence. We pray that Israel and the Jewish People will remain strong, idealistic and humane. We pray for peace in Israel, throughout the Middle East and throughout the world. We pray that all good people everywhere will foster love, not hatred; mutual respect, not enmity; kindness, not cruelty.

Realism demands that we see things as they are. Idealism demands that we see things as they can and should be. We must never let realism block out our idealism. We dream of—and work for—better days.

There are worrying trends in American life. Yet we celebrate Thanksgiving with the faith that the American Dream has the power to maintain our country as a bastion of freedom and democracy. The American Jewish community has made—and continues to make—monumental contributions to American life in so many areas. We are grateful for the blessings of America.

In his famous letter to the Jewish community of Newport in 1790, President George Washington wrote: "May the children of the stock of Abraham who dwell in this land continue to merit and enjoy the good will of the other inhabitants--while everyone shall sit in safety under his own vine and fig tree and there shall be none to make him afraid." These are words, expressive of the American spirit at its best, for which we can be thankful.

On April 17, 1818, Mordecai Manuel Noah--one of the great American Jews of his time--delivered an address at the dedication ceremony of Shearith Israel's second synagogue building on Mill Street in lower Manhattan. He closed his talk with a prayer that we invoke this Thanksgiving:  "May we prove ever worthy of God's blessing; may He look down from His heavenly abode, and send us peace and comfort; may He instill in our minds a love of country, of friends, and of all mankind.  Be just, therefore, and fear not.  That God who brought us out of the land of Egypt, who walked before us like 'a cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night,' will never desert His people Israel."

Happy Thanksgiving.

Hope and the Discipline of Integration

 

It is a common mistake to treat hope as an emotion. We often passively wait for it, expecting it to arrive only when circumstances improve or the news softens. But feelings are notoriously fragile. When history grows heavy and the present feels unmanageable, an emotion-based optimism simply evaporates, leaving cynicism in its wake. The Torah recognises this vulnerability and responds with a profound shift in categories: in the Jewish lexicon, hope is a discipline.

The Tanakh gives this discipline a specific name—tikva—and grounds it in a strikingly physical image. Derived from the word for a cord or a measuring line (kav), tikva is a figurative tether. It is a rope anchoring the individual to the solid ground of a promised future. The defining challenge of covenantal life is learning how to hold on. Indeed, gripping that tether requires immense strength. Jewish history has provided more than enough empirical evidence to justify despair, and the temptation to accept hopelessness as a sober realism is constant. Yet, the tradition flatly refuses this surrender. Instead, it offers a rigorous education in endurance, crafting an inner architecture that allows a people to build across generations. To understand how Judaism trains us to keep our eyes on the horizon, we first have to start where the Torah so often does: with the raw, flawed reality of the human animal.

Fundamentally, human beings are born into immediacy. The present arrives with hunger, fear, fatigue, status anxiety, and the need to belong. Under stress, the mind defaults toward short-range relief. Contemporary cognitive science describes this as fast, survival-oriented cognition that prioritizes immediate safety and reward. The Torah describes the same phenomenon in older language: the yetzer (“inclination”) presses the person toward what is urgent, pleasurable, and socially safe. Immediacy has a distinctive signature. It narrows perception and it shortens time. It makes the invisible feel unreal and it turns the future into a rumor. Once that narrowing sets in, the world begins to look smaller than it is, and the self begins to live inside a collapsing frame.

The story of Gan Eden perfectly illustrates this collapse. The unraveling starts simply, with a shift in attention where the world is reduced to what can be consumed, and the self is reduced to pure appetite. As the present moment swells to consume everything else, the horizon completely vanishes. Cynicism easily creeps in here, masquerading as a sober reading of reality. It might feel like strength, but it is actually surrender. To counter this, the Torah introduces a different kind of strength entirely: the capacity to endure delay.

From the quiet unraveling in the garden, the Torah moves to the loud urgency of hunger, a tension brilliantly captured when Esau returns exhausted from the field. When hunger takes over as the ultimate authority, the body demands immediate satisfaction, and the mind quickly jumps to justify it. The birthright (bekhora) represents a future that cannot yet be tasted—continuity, responsibility, and obligation. Yet, under the crushing weight of immediate appetite, that future evaporates. Esav’s brutal question, “What use is a bekhora to me?” exposes a worldview incapable of letting the future govern the present. It marks the exact moment the tether snaps. Jacob, however, treats the horizon as something real. For him, the covenant (berit) isn't just a lofty ideal, but the very framework that organizes his priorities.

Once this pattern is established, the Torah returns to it again and again, tracing the same discipline across different kinds of pressure. Joseph lives it in a pit, in a prison, and in a palace. A life that could have collapsed into bitterness becomes an instrument of preservation because Joseph continues to act as though tomorrow still belongs to God. Moses lives it when he confronts a people conditioned by slavery: the first task is time. Shabbat appears in the wilderness before Sinai because a freed people requires control over their time before it can carry a law. That word—tikva—names the discipline of treating a distant good as binding, even when the present presses for a quicker verdict.

If the Torah’s narratives show the discipline, one scene turns it into a literal picture. The most concrete image of tikva appears at a window in Jericho. The spies instruct Rahab to bind a scarlet cord as a sign for rescue. The verse calls it tikvat ḥut ha-shani (“a cord of scarlet thread”). A future deliverance is attached to a physical tether. Rescue becomes legible, and promise becomes actionable. The horizon is secured through a literal binding. That is how hope functions in Jewish psychology. It becomes real when it is tethered to practices that hold steady under pressure. A horizon requires reinforcement, since a human being is not built to carry a distant good on emotion alone. Judaism supplies the reinforcement through mitzvot/commandments.

At their most basic level, the commandments place intentional friction at the pressure points where human beings lose sovereignty: consumption, speech, sexuality, anger, pride, and the use of time. These commandments operate as training. They insert a pause between stimulus and response, so that the future can re-enter the decision. We see this practically in the rhythm of daily Jewish life. Speaking a berakha before eating forces meaning to arrive before consumption, teaching our appetite restraint through language. A mezuza physically interrupts your entry into a room, turning a simple threshold into a reminder of ultimate reality.⁸ Instead of just pausing the workweek, Shabbat actively halts the engine of endless productivity and comparison, reclaiming time as a space for service rather than a treadmill of self-justification. Together, this system of commandments cultivates what our Sages call yishuv ha-daʿat—a settled mind. Through consistent practice, it produces a person capable of absorbing uncertainty without sacrificing their future.

As ever, Rambam’s language clarifies this dynamic. He is forthright in declaring that human character is formed by repeated actions until stable dispositions are acquired. A person becomes what the person repeatedly chooses. Commandments therefore function as an education of the will. The will grows strong enough to carry delay, refuse panic, and endure social pressure without dissolving. This is where tikva becomes durable: hope becomes embodied.

Once hope is embodied, waiting itself stops being empty time. The Torah contains rituals that turn waiting into a skill! For example, counting the omer (sefirat ha-omer) translates 49 days into an ascent toward Sinai. Each day becomes a step, and human anticipation becomes structured. The Berit teaches a people how to carry a future in the body, one day at a time.

Communal life takes these deeply personal rituals and magnifies them. Jewish education is perhaps the greatest example of this. Building schools, printing texts, and dedicating years to teaching children and adults rarely yields immediate applause. It demands tremendous expenditure, patience, and trust. The real harvest arrives decades later, visible when young adults hold fast to their identity under pressure, or when a community raises leaders capable of thinking beyond the crisis of the moment. This is tikva made entirely concrete: investing in a tomorrow that requires deep sacrifice today. We see this exact dynamic echoing through our national narratives—like Nehemiah rebuilding the walls of Jerusalem with a trowel in one hand and a sword in the other!

All of this discipline ultimately aims at shelemut (wholeness/integration). A shalem (integrated) person aligns desire, action, and purpose into a single ordered self. Appetite and fear remain part of the human being, yet they operate under governance. Such a person meets reality with clarity, carries setbacks without collapse, and handles success without intoxication. The Torah’s anthropology assumes that inner order is achievable. The technology of commandments form the person who can live in that order.

From there, communal optimism becomes intelligible, because a community is the aggregate of what its people have been trained to carry. Jewish students who stand visibly Jewish on difficult campuses embody a refusal to let immediate social pressure overwrite identity. Parents investing in Jewish education embody a collective willingness to delay gratification for a holy future. Communities creating new frameworks of learning and hesed embody a long horizon. And where have Jews settled and not built communities? The rebuilding of Israel embodies the same capacity at civilizational scale: a society willing to absorb strain because the future is treated as real. This optimism therefore functions less as prediction and more as discipline. A future remains visible because the tradition trains the mind to keep it visible—by binding the horizon to habits that do not collapse when the present tightens its grip.

In the spirit of the theme of this volume of Conversations, the glass feels half full because Jewish life holds a pitcher: the covenantal tether of tikva, the technology of mitzvot, and the human goal of shelemut. Hope becomes a deliberate, joyful act of construction. The horizon stays open because our people have learned how to hold it—not just in thought, but in action.

This disciplined optimism is perfectly crystallised by the late, great Rabbi Matloub Abadi (1889–1970), who framed this tether as a direct charge to the architects of our future:

 

Happy shall you be if you use this time for the good of the Land, the pride of our past and the luminescence of our future, to fulfil your duty toward it and to help it with all the means and the ways leading to rebuilding its ruins and making its settlement bloom. Remember our pledge to Zion on the rivers of Babylon and our aspiration and prayers to it over all generations. Do not be among those who falter behind its camps; be in the first ranks of its defenders and the fighters for its freedom, and take an important place among its loyal sons and builders. 

 

 

Paired Perspectives on the Parashah: Vayetzei

Vayetzei:

Leah’s Eyes

 

The Torah’s introduction of Rachel and Leah contains the roots of their conflict: “Leah had weak (or soft) eyes; Rachel was shapely and beautiful” (Genesis 29:17). Clearly, Rachel was the more physically attractive of the two sisters. But why does the Torah specifically mention Leah’s eyes?

From ancient times, eyes have represented a window into one’s soul. Perhaps Leah’s eyes suggest an inner depth that is not immediately apparent from outward appearances. Although Rachel’s physical beauty captured Jacob’s attention, Leah possessed qualities that would emerge gradually over time.

The Torah gives Leah a forum to express her deepest feelings through the names she gives her children. Reuben: “The Lord has seen my affliction; it also means: Now my husband will love me.” Simeon: “The Lord heard that I was unloved and has given me this one also.” Levi: “This time my husband will become attached to me” (29:31–34). Leah’s words reveal her longing for Jacob’s love and her persistent hope that their relationship might deepen.

Jacob’s preference for Rachel continued to shape the family long after these children were born. Following Rachel’s death, Jacob favored her firstborn, Joseph. After the brothers sold Joseph and Jacob believed him dead, Jacob became especially protective of Benjamin, Rachel’s remaining son.

Yet the narrative gradually reveals the greatness of Leah’s descendants, particularly Judah. When Benjamin faced enslavement in Egypt, Judah offered himself in his brother’s place. Although Judah had suffered from the family tensions generated by Jacob’s favoritism, he demonstrated extraordinary courage, responsibility, and love for his brother.

The Torah does not explicitly state that Jacob learned of Judah’s willingness to sacrifice himself for Benjamin. Nevertheless, the narrative invites readers to recognize Judah’s moral transformation and to consider its significance for Jacob’s final blessings. On his deathbed, Jacob granted Joseph an extraordinary blessing, but he bestowed the promise of kingship upon Judah: “The scepter shall not depart from Judah” (49:10).

In this sense, the quiet strength and perseverance associated with Leah ultimately emerged through her descendants.

Strikingly, Jacob was buried alongside Leah in the Cave of Machpelah. Rachel enjoyed Jacob’s passionate love throughout her lifetime, but Jacob rests eternally beside Leah. The contrast offers a poignant conclusion to the sisters’ complicated relationship.

Despite Jacob’s promise of kingship to Judah, Israel’s first king came from the tribe of Benjamin, descended from Rachel. Saul is introduced as exceptionally handsome and physically imposing (1 Samuel 9:2). When he stood before the people, his impressive stature reinforced their enthusiasm for him (10:23–24). Yet Saul ultimately failed to establish an enduring dynasty.

When Samuel searched for Saul’s successor, he initially favored the impressive appearance of Jesse’s son Eliab. God corrected him: “For not as man sees [does the Lord see]; man sees only what is visible, but the Lord sees into the heart” (1 Samuel 16:7).

David, descended from Judah and Leah, then appeared: “He was ruddy-cheeked, bright-eyed, and handsome” (16:12). This description introduces an important qualification. David himself was physically attractive. The Torah's contrast, therefore, is not between beauty and its absence, but between outward appearance and the deeper qualities that determine a person’s worthiness. Saul’s impressive appearance did not guarantee successful kingship, and Samuel's initial attraction to Eliab’s stature proved misleading. God chose David because He saw what human beings could not immediately perceive.

The reference to David’s beautiful eyes is particularly suggestive. Like his ancestor Leah, whose eyes distinguished her in the Torah’s introduction, David is characterized in part through his eyes. Yet whereas Leah’s eyes invite readers to look beyond conventional beauty, David’s description combines physical attractiveness with the inner qualities that God recognizes.

The rabbinic tradition concerning the messianic age offers a further development of this pattern. The Sages speak of Messiah ben Joseph, who will die, and Messiah ben David, associated with the ultimate redemption (Sukkah 52a–b). Although this tradition does not explicitly connect the two messianic figures to Rachel and Leah, their respective tribal lineages invite a literary comparison with the earlier biblical narratives.

Once again, the line of Joseph appears first, but the enduring fulfillment emerges through the house of David.

Jacob’s family history, the establishment of Israel’s monarchy, and the rabbinic vision of redemption thus suggest a recurring lesson. Human beings naturally respond to visible beauty and impressive appearances. Yet these qualities alone cannot reveal the deeper character upon which lasting greatness depends.

Rachel’s beauty immediately captured Jacob’s heart. Leah’s greatness emerged more quietly, through perseverance, devotion, and the moral achievements of her descendants.

People often recognize physical beauty first, but enduring greatness may be found in the depth of Leah’s eyes.

A Free Guide on Conversion to Judaism

What I wished was in one place

Earlier this year I stood in front of a Beit Din in Israel and answered questions I had been studying for a long time. I am originally from Moscow and I live in Tel Aviv, where I work as a financial analyst. Nothing in that sentence explains why I spent my evenings building a website for conversion candidates, so let me try.

When I began the process I expected the hard part to be the content. Shabbat, kashrut, the order of the prayers, the laws of family life, the holidays and their reasons. The content was hard, but it was not the hardest part. The hardest part was that it lived in so many places. One topic was in a photocopied booklet from class, another in a Hebrew sefer I could read only slowly, a third in a forum thread where half the answers contradicted each other. More than once I knew I had seen an answer in four places and could not find it in any of them. Candidates who think in Russian have it worse, because the good material is mostly in Hebrew or English, and the Russian material is often outdated or written by people who never sat in front of a Beit Din themselves.

So I started keeping my own list of questions and answers. After my giur, the list became Jewish Path.

Jewish Path https://jewishpath.online/en  is a free site in English, Russian and Hebrew. There are eleven study topics, written the way I would have wanted them explained to me: what the halacha is, where it comes from, and what it looks like on an ordinary Tuesday. There are 153 practice questions of the kind a Beit Din actually asks, with answers, and flashcards for the ones that refuse to stay in memory. Each week there is a short summary of the parasha in all three languages. There is also a blog on practical halacha, the first time you put up a mezuzah, the first time you kasher a kitchen, how a visit to the mikveh works, written for the person who is doing it for the first time and is a little embarrassed to ask.

Two things about the site I want to say plainly. There are no ads and nothing for sale. And it is a study companion, not a program. Every page says to follow one's sponsoring rabbi. A candidate who reads something on the site and hears something different from their rabbi should follow their rabbi. The site exists to make the hours between classes more useful, not to replace the teacher.

The halachic material draws on the Shulchan Aruch, the Mishnah Berurah, the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch and the standard Orthodox guides, and the practice questions follow the curriculum I studied in Israel. I have asked rabbis to review it and I keep asking. When a rabbi wrote to me recently about something on the site that should not have been there, I removed it the same day. I would rather be corrected than be read uncritically, and I say so to everyone who writes.

Why three languages? Because the people who need this are rarely one kind of person. In my own program there were Israelis who grew up in Jewish homes with a non-Jewish mother, new immigrants from Russia and Ukraine who learned about their family history late, Americans who came for a year and stayed, and spouses of all of the above. They sat in the same room and took notes in different alphabets. A site that spoke to only one of them would have missed the others, and often it is the same person who studies in Hebrew and thinks in Russian.

I do not know how many people the site will reach. What I do know is the feeling of finding a clear answer at eleven at night when the next class is on Thursday, and I would like other candidates to have that feeling more often. If you work with people on this road, the link costs nothing to pass along. And if you read something on the site that is wrong, missing or explained badly, please write to me at [email protected]. Every such letter makes it better for the next person.
 


 

Please Stand With Us: End of Year Campaign

Archaeology and Tanakh: What It Can—and Cannot—Teach Us

 

Over the past two centuries, archaeology has transformed the study of the ancient world. Periodically, a dramatic announcement appears in the news: an inscription, a seal, or a structure that allegedly sheds new light on the biblical period. The reactions tend to be immediate and predictable. People of faith celebrate: at last, the truth of Tanakh has been proven. Some scholars respond just as quickly in the opposite direction, dismissing the find as a forgery or a misinterpretation. A debate ensues, and before long, public attention moves elsewhere.

Despite their differences, both reactions share a common assumption: that Tanakh stands or falls based on external validation. If archaeology confirms it, then it is true; if archaeology challenges it, then it is suspect. This framing, however widespread, is fundamentally flawed.

The problem begins with a misunderstanding of what Tanakh is. Tanakh contains a great deal of history, but it is not “history as it really was” in the sense defined by the nineteenth-century historian Leopold von Ranke. Rather, it is historiosophy—a divinely guided interpretation of history that conveys meaning, not merely events. Its goal is not to provide a neutral chronicle of the past, but to teach enduring truths about God, humanity, and the covenantal relationship between them.

Once this point is recognized, the limitations of archaeology become clearer. Archaeology is not an experimental science; it cannot recreate the past under controlled conditions. It works with fragmentary remains, incomplete data, and interpretive judgments. Arguments from silence—claims that something did not exist because we have not yet found evidence for it—are inherently weak. Tomorrow’s discovery may overturn today’s consensus, or it may be that we would not reasonably expect to find such evidence in the first place.

For this reason, attempts to use archaeology to “prove” or “disprove” Tanakh are misguided from the outset. Some readers approach Tanakh as entirely and literally true in every detail. Others adopt a more flexible stance, generally trusting the biblical record unless clear evidence suggests otherwise. Still others assume that Tanakh has little or no historical value unless independently corroborated. These positions differ sharply, but they share a common error: they assign archaeology a role it cannot fulfill.

Classical Jewish thinkers offer a more nuanced approach. Figures such as Rambam and Rabbi Saadyah Gaon maintained that truth is unified—there can be no ultimate conflict between Torah and genuine knowledge of the world. At the same time, they recognized that our interpretations, whether of Scripture or of empirical data, are fallible.[1] This principle applies equally to the interpretation of archaeological data, which is itself tentative and subject to revision.

Moreover, even from within the field of archaeology itself, the picture is far from one-sided. Gary Rendsburg has argued that the broad contours of Israel’s history align well with the archaeological record, apart from certain debated areas—most notably the extent of the united monarchy.[2] Kenneth Kitchen likewise emphasizes the general reliability of the biblical record within its ancient Near Eastern context.[3]

In light of all this, the question is not whether archaeology can validate Tanakh in some absolute sense. It cannot. The more fruitful question is how archaeology can be used as a tool to deepen our understanding of Tanakh as the word of God.

Once we move beyond the unproductive search for external proof, archaeology opens up a range of meaningful possibilities. One particularly important area is the study of Tanakh in its ancient cultural context. Over time, scholarship has moved through several phases: first seeking to confirm Tanakh, then arguing that it borrowed from surrounding mythologies, and more recently recognizing that Tanakh engages its environment while transforming it in profound ways.

Several examples illustrate this dynamic. In the ancient world, myths of immortality were widespread. Other cultures emphasized a “Tree of Life,” reflecting a deep human desire to transcend death. In the Garden of Eden narrative, however, the Tree of Life plays only a secondary role. The central element is the Tree of Knowledge. As Umberto Cassuto observed, this shift is striking. The Torah is not primarily concerned with immortality, but with moral and spiritual knowledge—how human beings ought to live in this world.

Similarly, circumcision was practiced in various ancient societies, often as a rite of passage into manhood. In the Torah, however, it is transformed into a sign of covenant. As Leon Kass has argued, this redefinition is profound. Manhood is no longer measured by physical potency, but by the capacity to sustain and transmit a covenantal relationship across generations. The act points beyond itself to a lifelong responsibility.[4]

A third example may be seen in the principle of lex talionis—“an eye for an eye.” Ancient law collections, such as that of Hammurabi, also recognized bodily injury as a matter of legal concern (see laws 196–198). Yet the Torah’s formulation introduces a critical innovation: the law applies equally to all members of society. The dignity of the individual is not contingent on social status, but rooted in a shared moral framework under God.

In each case, Tanakh does not merely echo its environment; it reshapes it. Archaeology allows us to see this process more clearly by providing the broader cultural backdrop against which the Torah’s message emerges.

Beyond these conceptual insights, archaeology also serves as a practical tool for interpreting the biblical text. Already in the Talmudic and medieval periods, sages drew on real-world knowledge to clarify details of Tanakh. The Talmud (Sukkah 5a) records that when Rabbi Elazar visited Rome, he saw Temple vessels, including the tzitz, the High Priest’s golden headband, and reported on its appearance. The Arch of Titus informs our understanding of the design of the Temple menorah. Ramban revised his understanding of the geography of Rachel’s burial place after arriving in the Land of Israel and seeing the terrain firsthand (see his commentary on Genesis 35:16).

Material discoveries likewise illuminate specific terms and practices. The “pim” mentioned in I Samuel (13:21), once obscure, has been identified through archaeological finds as a particular weight, helping to clarify the verse. Linguistic advances, drawing on Akkadian, Ugaritic, Egyptian, and other ancient languages, have deepened our understanding of biblical vocabulary, much as earlier commentators used Aramaic and Arabic as cognates. Even historical context—knowledge of Assyrian, Babylonian, and Persian imperial practices—enables a richer reading of the prophetic books.

All of this falls under the category of using archaeology as a tool for understanding God’s word in Tanakh. It sharpens our reading, clarifies ambiguities, and situates Tanakh within the lived reality of the ancient world.

Perhaps the most powerful example of this approach lies in the study of covenant. Scholars have noted parallels between the structure of biblical covenantal texts and ancient Near Eastern treaties, particularly those of the Hittites.[5] These treaties typically include a preamble identifying the ruler, a historical prologue, stipulations, and a list of blessings and curses.

The Torah adopts a similar structure for the revelation at Sinai. Yet the similarities only highlight the profound differences. In the ancient world, treaties were agreements between a powerful ruler and a subordinate vassal. In the Torah, the covenant is between a transcendent God and an entire nation. The laws are issued not by a king or sage, but by God Himself. The covenant is eternal, embedded in a narrative that gives it meaning, and addressed to every member of the community.[6]

Moreover, the Torah introduces concepts with no true parallel in the ancient world: the prohibition against representing God physically, and the demand for inner moral integrity, extending even to one’s desires. As Samson Raphael Hirsch noted, the very notion that a law could govern human thought and emotion points to a divine origin beyond the reach of ordinary legislation.

Here, too, archaeology and comparative study do not diminish the uniqueness of Tanakh—they bring it into sharper focus. By understanding the familiar forms, we can better appreciate the revolutionary content.

In the end, the role of archaeology in the study of Tanakh is both significant and limited. It cannot determine the truth of Tanakh, nor should it be asked to do so. Attempts to use it as a final arbiter are bound to fail, as scholars will continue to debate fragmentary evidence and incomplete data.

At the same time, when used properly, archaeology is an invaluable resource. It enriches our understanding of language, geography, historical context, and cultural background. It allows us to see more clearly how Tanakh speaks within its world—and how it transforms that world through its message.

“What happened” in history matters. But for the religious reader, what Tanakh teaches through history matters much more. Archaeology uncovers the physical remains of ancient civilizations; Tanakh reveals the meaning of human existence. When approached with clarity and intellectual honesty, the former can illuminate the latter—but it can never replace it.[7]

 


 


[1] For further discussion, see Hayyim Angel, “Controversies over the Historicity of Biblical Passages in Traditional Commentary,” in Angel, From Ideas to Ideals: A Collection of Essays by Rabbi Hayyim Angel (Conversations 44, Fall 2024) (New York: Institute for Jewish Ideas and Ideals), 202–213.

[2] Gary S. Rendsburg, “Israel without the Bible,” in The Hebrew Bible: New Insights and Scholarship, ed. Frederick E. Greenspahn (New York: New York University Press, 2008), 3–23.

[3] Kenneth A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: W. B. Eerdmans, 2003).

[4] Leon R. Kass, The Beginning of Wisdom: Reading Genesis (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003), 313.

[5] See Jon D. Levenson, Sinai and Zion: An Entry into the Jewish Bible (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1987), 23–36.

[6] See Nahum M. Sarna, Exploring Exodus: The Heritage of Biblical Israel (New York: Schocken Books, 1996), 140–144.

[7] For extensive discussion of this topic, see Amnon Bazak, To This Very Day: Fundamental Questions in Bible Study, trans. Kaeren Fish with Elka Weber (Jerusalem: Maggid, 2020), 237–333; Joshua Berman, Ani Maamin: Biblical Criticism, Historical Truth, and the Thirteen Principles of Faith (Jerusalem: Maggid, 2020), 3–75.

The Human Complexity of Biblical Heroes

 

In several areas of Jewish thought, more conservative positions only achieved dominance in modernity. For example, most rishonim (medieval authorities) believed in the natural order before Ramhal (R. Moshe Hayyim Luzzatto), R. Eliyahu Dessler, and others declared that nature was an illusion and that our human efforts produce no direct causal result. The same applies to attitude towards our biblical heroes. R. Dessler and R. Aaron Kotler avoid attributing basic human emotions to our patriarchs and matriarchs, forbid criticizing them, and depict their sins as the minutest of transgressions. However, Radak and Ramban did not interpret in this fashion nor did R. Samson Raphael Hirsch and Neziv. Arguably, R. Dessler type thinking on this topic only became widespread in the twentieth century. 

Before addressing twentieth century rabbinic luminaries, I shall use a lesser-known recent volume as a foil to help convey the issues at hand. R. Beinish Ginsburg, teacher for many years at Netiv Aryeh and Michlala, published a volume on Genesis entitled Ohr le-Netivati which includes several concluding chapters about the correct approach to the avot (patriarchs). After extended analysis of this work, we shall briefly confront the work of R. Avigdor Nebenzahl as well as other famous rabbinic predecessors. Analysis of Ohr le-Netivati reveals a one-sided presentation of traditional sources and shows how this ideology hinders our biblical study. Ginsburg very much belongs in the R. Dessler camp and let us explore the results.

The significant question here is not only whether we can fault our luminaries, but also whether we can attribute basic human emotion to them. In one example, avoiding this makes a patriarch look worse. According to Ginsburg: 

 

But at the same time, the fact that he woke up early reflects that he slept the night before. Avraham Avinu was so secure in his avodas Hashem (service of God), so confident that he was doing the right thing, that he managed to fall asleep despite the nisayon (test) that awaited him the next morning (the akedah).[1]

 

I would think more highly of Abraham had he experienced trouble sleeping the night before embarking on a journey to slaughter his son, divine command notwithstanding. R. Aharon Lichtenstein criticizes those who think Abraham went to the akedah as if he was attending a wedding.[2] 

Ginsburg states that the faithful never worry once they know the correct course of action.[3] This does not match the storyline in Genesis where Abraham is afraid (15:1), Isaac is frightened (26:24) and Jacob appears nervous on multiple occasions (32:8, 48:3). The traditional commentaries on those verses often work against Ginsburg's thesis. If Abraham was afraid that the four kings would vengefully attack or that he has used up his heavenly reward, these are fears about practical results and not about the correct course of action.[4] It seems quite normal and human to be nervous about either an upcoming war or the aftermath of a military conflict. 

The same applies to the very natural fear of death. Ginsburg quotes R. Avigdor Miller on Rachel's attitude to mortality. "She did not fear death because of death itself. Death was a grief because she would no longer bear any sons to build the house of Israel."[5] I would not think less of Rachel if she was upset on a personal level and not only because of an inability to further contribute to Jewish destiny. If Rachel feared not surviving long enough to spend more time with her two sons, including one who was just born, I would actually think more of her. R. Joseph Soloveitchik, for one, was not embarrassed to write about his illustrious grandfather's fear of death.[6]

One midrash emphasizes that Jacob and Moses were frightened despite their receiving divine promises and holds them up as a model for emulation. Hazal (our Talmudic sages) apparently did not view apprehension as religiously derelict.   

 

“Jacob was very frightened and distressed” – R. Pinḥas in the name of R. Reuben: The Holy One blessed be He made a promise to two people, but they were afraid; the chosen of the patriarchs, and the chosen of the prophets. The chosen of the patriarchs – this is Jacob, as it is stated: “For the Lord has chosen Jacob for Himself” (Psalms 135:4). The Holy One blessed be He said to him: “Behold, emphasizes I am with you” (Genesis 28:15), but ultimately he was afraid, as it is stated: “Jacob was…frightened.” The chosen of the prophets – this is Moses, as it is stated; “Were it not for Moses, His chosen” (Psalms 106:23). The Holy One blessed be He said to him: “For I will be with you” (Exodus 3:12), but ultimately, he was afraid: “The Lord said to Moses: Do not fear him” (Numbers 21:34). He says: ‘Do not fear’ only to one who is afraid. 

 

R. Berekhya and R. Ḥelbo in the name of R. Shmuel bar Naḥman in the name of R. Natan: Israel would have been worthy of elimination in the days of Haman, had they not based their mindset on the mindset of their ancestor. They said: ‘If our patriarch Jacob, to whom the Holy One blessed be He promised and said: “Behold, I am with you,” (Genesis 28:15) was afraid, we, all the more so.’ (Bereishit Rabba 76:1).

 

     In another portrayal of a biblical character as transcending basic humanity, Ginsburg cites R. Meir Twersky who denies that Rachel was jealous of her sister's children; she only envied Leah's good deeds which enabled the older sibling to merit offspring.[7] Hazal do indeed suggest this (Bereishit Rabba 71:6) but Radak has no problem saying Rachel was jealous of Leah for having children.[8] Imagine the situation. If not for a deceit in which Leah participated, Rachel would be the sole wife of Jacob but now she has to share her husband with her sister. To add to her frustration, Rachel remains barren as her sister quickly produces four children. Surely, it would be understandable and not a moral failure to experience some resentment and jealousy. 

None of the above examples involve transgression; they merely reflect simple humanity. If we deny these feelings to the avot and imahot (matriarchs), we render them irrelevant to us, who experience the full range of human emotions, as models. As noted, in some instances, we may actually be lowering their stature. 

Hazal alreadypresent a multitude of perspectives on biblical heroes. The same Talmudic passage stating it is mistaken to say that King David sinned in the Bat Sheva episode also includes Rav saying that R. Yehuda Hanasi went out of his way to exonerate this monarch only because he descended from the Davidic line (Shabbat 56a). Furthermore, another gemara suggests that David was guilty of both adultery and rape (Ketuvot 9a). One midrash faults Jacob for not responding with enough sympathy to his frustrated wife (Bereishit Rabba 71:7). On occasion, the sages even introduce problematic behavior not explicitly in the biblical narrative. A gemara says that Joseph stayed behind that fateful day fully intending to sleep with Potiphar’s wife but was able to restrain himself at the last minute (Sotah 10b). Our sages were not singularly dedicated to whitewashing our heroes.   

Many classic commentaries assume a normal psychological makeup for our forefathers in Genesis. Why is Joseph the favored ben zekunim (child of his advanced years) if Benjamin was actually younger? Hizkuni explains that Jacob was never able to love Benjamin as he loved Joseph because he always associated Benjamin with the death of Rachel.[9] This reaction does not reflect negatively on Jacob but it does show the complexities and difficulties of human experience. Hizkuni also suggests that the brothers sold Joseph into slavery in an attempt to save themselves from the prophecy of brit bein habetarim (the covenant between the pieces); they hoped to restrict the foreseen servitude to Joseph and his family.[10] This is quite different from asserting that the brothers convened a beit din (court) and ruled that Joseph was a rodef (a dangerous pursuer). Denying normal human apprehensions and frustrations to our biblical heroes robs biblical narrative of sensitivity and insight. 

R. David Kimhi (Radak) consistently relates to the avot and imahot as great but flawed humans. He faults Sarai for her treatment of Hagar, calling it "not the way of ethics or of the pious". In fact, the Torah includes the Hagar story to instruct us regarding this very ethical message.[11]  For Radak, a reader who defends Sarai misses the entire point. Radak also says Jacob was punished for his method of acquiring the bekhora (privileges of the first born) from Esau. His penalty was that he ultimately had to honor his brother (precisely what he tried to avoid by purchasing the bekhora) when they met after a twenty year hiatus.[12] Where one opinion in Hazal states that Reuben merely moved his father's bed (Shabbat 55b), Radak follows the simple meaning of the verse that Reuven slept with Bilhah.[13] Radak even goes so far as to explain that Joseph told his brothers his dreams in order to pain them in response to their hatred.[14] Nor do our biblical greats' errors only relate to the sinful variety. Radak suggests that Rivkah misunderstood her husband's plan to bless Esau. The birkat Abraham (blessing of Abraham) was going to pass on to Jacob with or without a blessing from his father; therefore, there was no need to fool Isaac in order to receive the blessing.[15] 

Ramban walks along the same path. Ginsburg alludes to Ramban attributing sin to Abraham but does not quote the relevant passages which contradict his position.[16] 

Know that Abraham our father unintentionally committed a great sin by bringing his wife to a stumbling block of sin on account of his fear for his life. He should have trusted that God would save him and his wife and all his belongings for God surely has the power to help and to save. His leaving the Land, concerning which he had been commanded from the beginning, on account of the famine, was also a sin he committed, for in famine God would redeem him from death. It was because of this deed that the exile in the land of Egypt at the hands of Pharaoh was decreed for his children.[17]   (Charles Chavel translation)

Ramban faults Abraham for endangering his wife, lack of faith, and leaving the Land of Israel. While he does mitigate blame by saying that the transgression was not intentional, he also refers to it as a "great sin." He does not emphasize that this was only a sin for someone on Abraham's level.[18] Parenthetically, I note that Radak defends Abraham in this episode; willingness to criticize does not entail always doing so.[19]

The driving out of Hagar inspires a parallel reaction. 

Our mother did transgress by this affliction and Abraham also by permitting her to do so. And so, God heard her [Hagar's] affliction and gave her a son who would be a wild-ass of a man, to afflict the seed of Abraham and Sarah with all kinds of affliction.[20] 

Note that Ramban thinks both transgressions were serious enough to cause long-term punishment. Regarding the category of making mistakes not necessarily sinful, Ramban explains that Abraham misjudged the character of Abimelech and Gerar and, unlike in Egypt, Sarah was not truly in danger.[21]

Ginsburg argues that Ramban frequently refers to the avot as zaddikim (righteous) so he cannot be attributing serious transgressions to them.[22] This line of reasoning highlights the problem with the entire approach. Righteous people are not infallible and they can stumble religiously and ethically. Given the pressures of a famine and a dangerous foreign country, even an Abraham can fall into a "great sin." 

His presentation of Rambam also leaves what to be desired. Ginsburg cites a passage in Guide to the Perplexed where Rambam says that Moses and the three patriarchs were all able to cling to God even as they engaged in mundane activities.[23] For Ginsburg, this shows how different they were from normal humans. However, the seventh chapter of Shmoneh Perakim (Rambam's introduction to Avot) strikes a very different note. Rambam says that a prophet must excel in the intellectual and moral spheres but that he need not be perfect regarding every character trait. Thus, the following group all prophesied even though Solomon had an excessive libido, David had a streak of cruelty, Elijah was too angry, and Samuel was overly fearful. In the fourth chapter of that same work, Rambam says that Moses became inappropriately angry in the episode of the waters of Meribah. Apparently, heroic figures can still struggle with serious character flaws

Abravanel works with analogous assumptions. He notes how Esau asks Jacob about his wife and children but Jacob only answers about the children (33:5) and he explains that Jacob was embarrassed to tell his brother that he had four wives.[24] There is no claim that the righteous are above such embarrassment. Abravanel also thinks that the Egyptian exile was punishment for the sale of Joseph. They sold him into Egyptian slavery and they ended up in Egyptian servitude. The brothers "sinned a great sin in their groundless hatred for their brother Joseph and in their plotting to murder him." Reuben was not part of the plot but he did participate in the hatred. Joseph sinned inadvertently in his prideful reaction to his dreams, and Jacob sinned to some degree in favoring one child and giving Joseph the ketonet passim (ornamented tunic).[25] Abravanel does not try to minimize the brothers' transgression.       

He also relates to Noah as an individual with standard fears and concerns. After the deluge, Noah was saddened and scared because of the loss of friends and acquaintances, the lack of food, the possibility that the animal kingdom will overwhelm a small number of humans, and the potential repeat of the first fratricide. According to Abravanel, in the first verses of the ninth chapter, God reassures Noah regarding all four fears. For example, the allowance of meat consumption helps compensate for the reduced amount of vegetation available for eating.[26] Despite being a zaddik, Noah struggled with the trauma of a world destroyed.  

      Relying on R. Yehuda Copperman's critique of R. Shlomo Riskin, Ginsburg says that the latter takes a quote from R. Hirsch about Moses' humanity out of context.[27] Yet he fails to consider some far more telling Hirschian passages. 

The Torah never hides from us the faults, errors and weaknesses of our great men. Just by that it gives the stamp of veracity to what it relates. But in truth, by the knowledge which is given us of their faults and weaknesses, our great men are in no wise made lesser but actually greater and more instructive. If they stood before us as the purest models of perfection we should attribute them as having a different nature, which has been denied to us. Were they without passion without internal struggles, their outcome would seem to us the outcome of some higher nature, hardly a merit and surely no model we could hope to emulate (Isaac Levy translation).[28]

            R. Hirsch offers three arguments for a more human portrayal of our great men. One, it gives our stories the stamp of truth since it reflects the reality of humanity. Second, it actually enhances their greatness because it means that their achievements depended upon overcoming various character shortcomings and were not innate from birth. Finally, it makes them relevant role models for all of us who struggle with difficult personality traits. 

            His famous commentary on the education of Jacob and Esau echoes this theme: “Our sages, who never objected to draw attention to the small and great weaknesses in the history of our great forefathers and thereby make them just the more instructive for us.”[29]           He goes on to say that Isaac and Rebecca erred in giving Jacob and Esau the identical education when their needs were so diverse. The active and energetic Esau needed a different approach than the more contemplative, reserved Jacob. Additionally, Isaac and Rebecca mistakenly failed to exhibit equal love to each of their children. It seems that Copperman and Ginsburg are truly the ones distorting the views of R. Hirsch.

            R. Hirsch's approach to Simeon and Levi in Shechem also proves instructive. While, Ginsburg tries to downplay any wrongdoing, R. Hirsch is quite adamant about their transgressions.

 

Now the blameworthy part begins, which we need in no way excuse. Had they killed Shechem and Hamor there would scarcely be anything to say against it. But they did not spare the unarmed men who were at their mercy, yea, and went further, and looted, altogether made the inhabitants pay for the crime of the landowner. For that, there was no justification.[30]

 

            The juxtaposition of the chapter in which Jacob confronts Esau with the Shechem episode inspires a profound comment from R. Hirsch. In chapter 33, Esau overcomes his violent nature and embraces his brother. This contrasts sharply with the following story in which Simeon and Levi pick up the sword of Esau and engage in unjustified violence.[31]

            Strikingly, Ginsburg enlists Neziv (R. Naftali Zvi Yehuda Berlin) as a champion of his conservative approach even though Neziv very much humanized the patriarchs and matriarchs. R. Berlin explains that Rebecca was intimidated at her first sight of her husband, that this influenced their life-long relationship, and that she was unable to confront him directly as Rachel and Sarah did with their husbands. Therefore, she employed a deceptive strategy to get Jacob the blessing rather than just challenging Isaac's decision in an open conversation.[32] 

            Furthermore, Neziv explicitly contradicts Ginsburg's reading of a midrash which states that the great and bitter cry of Mordecai in Shushan was payment for the great and bitter cry that Jacob caused in Esau (Bereishit Rabba 67:4). Ginsburg asserts that this midrash does not deem Jacob's actions blameworthy.[33] In contrast, Neziv explains that one need not have pure motivations for mizva acts but one does need such purity for performing an avera lishmah (sin with a noble impetus); using a bad trait for a good cause must come without any personal pleasure. According to Neziv, this explains why Jacob was punished for his brother's cry but not for his father's tremble. He was pained by his father's reaction but took some problematic joy in his brother's distress. R. Berlin explicitly writes that such joy is forbidden and a sin.[34] 

            In one story, R. Berlin prefers a more human explanation over the alternative. How could Judah not have recognized the look or voice of Tamar, his daughter-in- law? Our sages suggest that this reflects Tamar's great modesty (Megilla 10b). The idea that Judah and Tamar lived as part of the same family for years without his knowing what she looks like certainly portrays their lives as radically distinct from ours. R. Berlin offers an explanation more rooted in basic human psychology. Judah first saw Tamar from afar and judged her a prostitute and, when he got closer, could not imagine that the decent Tamar was acting as a prostitute.[35] Indeed, we often get stuck in our preliminary judgment and cannot identify a person in an unexpected context.  

            Another midrash has Leah retort sharply to Jacob when he accuses her of deceit; she notes his own trickery in taking Esau's blessing (Bereishit Rabba 70:19). Ginsburg suggests a creative interpretation. 

 

This sounds like a rather strong criticism of Yaakov. But the meforshim on the midrash explain that the intention is entirely different. Leah was saying, "Everyone knows that Lavan's two daughters were destined to marry Rivka's two sons, and the oldest should go to the oldest. I'm supposed to marry the bechor – and you made yourself the bechor when you got the brachos.[36]   

 

Leah was arguing that even though she was originally destined for Esau since the older daughter should wed the eldest son, Jacob's usurping the bekhora now meant that Leah should marry Jacob, the newly established first-born. However, this is certainly not the simple reading of the midrash in which Leah asks Jacob: "is there a master without disciples;" in other words, I learned subterfuge from you.  This line relates to the morality of deceit and not to a question of correctly lined up marriage arrangements.   

Ginsburg misreads several other relevant sources as well. He quotes Ohr ha-Hayyim as explaining that Joseph knew his brothers acted with good intentions in selling him but Ohr ha-Hayyim does not say this. He does say that even at the time of the sale, Joseph continued to feel brotherhood with his siblings but this could be explained in many ways. A person can continue to love relatives even when they have intensely wronged him or her (45:4).[37]

I reiterate that the point is not only about wrongdoing; it is about having the aspirations and frustration of human beings. God states that He will not destroy Sodom without relating this news to Abraham first (18:17). R. Meir Simha ha-Cohen from Dvinsk offers a profound explanation as to why our first patriarch needed to know. A compassionate person wants the effects of his compassion to last. Indeed, we all want to leave a legacy and this is especially a concern for the childless. Abraham had heroically saved Sodom in the battle with the four kings, and thus would understandably not be happy about its impending destruction.[38] R. Meir Simha assumes that Abraham shared the same kind of hopes and dreams as other human beings.    

One of Ginsburg's important influences is the writings of R. Avigdor Nebenzahl, Rosh Yeshiva at Netiv Aryeh and former chief rabbi of Jerusalem's Old City. In the two concluding chapters to his volume on Genesis, R. Nebenzahl defends both Reuben and David as being nobly motivated and not driven by physical desire. Reuben only slept with Bilhah to break her connection with Jacob and restore his father's proper place with Leah. David's mistake was relying on the Holy Spirit informing him that Bat Sheva and he were destined for each other.[39] Let us leave aside the fact that these interpretations have no basis in the biblical narrative. In fact, the prophet informs us that Bat Sheva (Samuel II 11:2) was good-looking, presumably explaining David's interest. One gemara cites the following line in the context of the David and Bat Sheva episode. "There is a small limb in man. If he starves it, it is satisfied. If he satiates it, it is starving" (Sanhedrin 107a), clearly relating the monarch's sin to sexual temptation. Furthermore, do the motivations suggested by R. Nebenzahl truly mitigate the sins? What would we think of someone who slept with his step-mother in order to restore his own mother's place? 

R. Nebenzahl brings support for the minimization of David's sin from the fact that David does not lose the kingship, unlike Saul who forfeits the monarchy for what seems like a relatively, lesser transgression.[40] Earlier authorities give different answers to that question. R. Yosef Albo mentions several explanations, none of which reduce David's sin. Perhaps David sinned in a personal matter whereas Saul erred in a matter of kingship. Alternatively, David repented immediately when Natan confronted him while Saul initially denied any wrongdoing to Samuel. R. Albo outlines a series of areas in which David had superior character to Saul but he never denies the adultery with Bat Sheva or the murder of Uriah.[41]   

Minimizing David's wrongdoing neutralizes some of the story's power. The opening verse relates that David resides in his Jerusalem palace while his men fight on the battlefield (Samuel II 11:1). This morally dubious practice starts the moral deterioration leading to the affair with Bat Sheva. David tries to send Uriah home to cover up his having impregnated Bat Sheva but Uriah refuses (Samuel II 11:8-13). Instead of viewing this as Uriah' rebelling against David's authority, we could see it as Uriah showing sensitivity to his comrades at the front in a way that the monarch does not. Alternatively, Uriah refuses because he suspects what David has done.[42] 

   Admittedly, Ginsburg's methodology has roots in recent rabbinic authorities. However, these rabbinic personalities differ from the many rabbinic voices we have surveyed and we have sufficient motivation to prefer the more human view of biblical heroes. A comparison of the two schools reading the sale of Joseph reveals good reason for our preference. Beit ha-Levi asserts that Yaakov’s extensive sadness was due to the loss of a tribe for Am Yisrael, and not so much because of grief over a deceased son.[43] I am unsure why extensive grief over a son's death is a problematic emotion, especially given the added guilt and responsibility Jacob felt for sending his son off on a mission from which he never returned (as Radak explains).[44] This approach neutralizes the very powerful human emotion of sadness for the loss of a beloved son.

R. Nosson Tzvi Finkel, the Alter from Slobodka, insists that no one did anything seriously wrong in the entire story. Jacob had good intentions in favoring Joseph, Joseph had good intentions in tale-bearing, and the brothers sincerely judged Joseph as a rodef. The brothers were punished for the minor flaw of having some jealousy in their hearts, even though that jealousy did not warp their judgment. Based on a midrash (Bereishit Rabba 84:17), he even finds a positive element in their sitting down to a meal.[45] Similarly, R. Hayyim Yaakov Goldvicht, former Rosh Yeshiva of Yeshivat Kerem be-Yavneh, understands their meal within the approach that justifies the brothers by saying they formed a rabbinic court, trying Joseph and finding him guilty. During legal deliberation, he says, they were forbidden to eat, so they naturally sat down for a meal following the verdict.[46] His interpretation misses out on the narrative's subtle use of the meal to indicate indifference to pain.

These readings do not cohere with the simplest reading of Humash, and thwart appreciation of the psychological and moral insights conveyed in the brothers’ sitting down to eat, as well as the potential motivation of the brothers according to Hizkuni. As noted, Hizkuni explains that the brothers wanted the prophesied servitude to take effect on their brother Joseph. Moreover, the overall approach deviates from the standard language of the major Rishonim. Note, for instance, Abravanel’s comfort in attributing significant blame all around.

 

R. Eliyahu Eliezer Dessler follows the path of the Alter. Jacob had a metaphysical right to grant Joseph more honor, but he sinned slightly in allowing personal affection into the picture as well.[47] As with Beit Ha-Levi, his approach seems to not value the most authentic human emotions. R. Dessler also attempts to justify Joseph’s relating his irritating dreams to his brothers. The truly righteous are so involved in otherworldly thoughts that they only get by in this world due to divine assistance. Since God wanted the Egyptian exile to begin, He removed His protection from Joseph, who then innocently told his brothers about the dreams.[48] In contrast, I suggest that a zaddik very much needs to understand human interaction even without God’s help.[49] 

In a footnote, Ginsburg says that attaching oneself to a gadol promotes the correct attitude to biblical interpretation. "If one sees and appreciates the greatness of the gedolim and witnesses how they have such complete self-control, by extrapolation one will assume that the Avos certainly had such perfect control."[50] In contrast, I posit that time around gedolim may actually lead in another direction. I have known several prominent rabbis in my time, some truly great and some not so great, but all of them knew of apprehension, frustration, and anger. Ironically enough, some of the contemporary gedolim Ginsburg cites are deeply flawed individuals, especially R. Avigdor Miller, by far the most cited rabbinic figure in the book.[51] Perusal of R. Miller's explanations for the Holocaust may be enough to show that well-known rabbis can have serious limitations. 

What is at stake here may be more serious than we initially think. The more conservative approach significantly infringes on our study of Tanakh since it prevents us from noticing many of the insights of our sacred scripture.  Furthermore, it hinders our identifying with biblical heroes and their human tribulations, robbing us of potential role models. Finally, introducing encounter with contemporary gedolim into the conversation is quite telling. In response to secularization and the weakening of religion in the modern era, religious communities responded with increased emphasis on clergy authority and clergy greatness. Both papal infallibility and daas Torah are modern innovations.[52] One contemporary manifestation of this is a strong reluctance to ever criticize prominent rabbis even if they utter insulting statements or defend abusers. Large parts of the Orthodox world (certainly not all) need a more critical attitude towards the rabbinate. There may be serious overlap between how we read Tanakh and how we relate to the shortcomings of today's rabbis. 

Of course, this does not entail going to the opposite extreme and claiming that the biblical luminaries were bad people.[53] Recall that we are discussing the gamut of human emotions and not just sinful behavior. Remember as well Radak's defense of Abraham's behavior in Egypt. Concluding that the avot do sin does not mean they always or invariably do so. Due to the complexity of human nature, great individuals also struggle with character weaknesses. Denial of that basic fact strays from the example of Radak, Ramban and R. Hirsch, robs Tanakh of some of its most powerful messages and leaves readers without authentic role models.[54]

  

 

 

 

Notes

    


 


[1] Beinish Ginsburg,  Ohr le-Nitavati, (henceforth OL), (2024), 131.

[2] R. Aharon Lichtenstein and R. Hayyim Sabato, Mevakshei Panekha (Tel Aviv, 2011), 200.

[3] OL, 343. On the patriarchs expressing fear despite divine promises, see my "No Guarantees in Life," Tradition (Summer 2022), 145–153. 

[4] See Rashi and Seforno Genesis 15:1.

[5] OL, 291.

[6] R. Joseph Dov Soloveitchik, Halakhic Man (Philadelphia, 1983), 73. 

[7] OL, 433.

[8] R. David Kimhi, Commentary on the Torah Genesis 30:1. 

[9] Hizkuni, Commentary on the Torah Genesis 37:3.

[10]Ibid., 37:27. 

[11] R. Davd Kimhi, Commentary on the Torah Genesis 16:6.

[12]Ibid., 25:31.

[13]Ibid., 35:22. See also R. Yosef Bekhor Shor's commentary on that verse.  

[14]Ibid., 37:5.

[15]Ibid., 27:5. 

[16]OL, 424.

[17]R. Moshe ben Nahman, Commentary on the Torah Genesis12:10. 

[18]Ibid. 16:6.

[19]R. David KImhi, Commentary on the Torah Genesis 12:12.

[20]R. Moshe ben Nahman, Commentary on the Torah, Genesis 16:6.

[21]Ibid., 20:2.

[22]OL, 422.

[23]Maimonides, Guide to the Perplexed Book 3, Chapter 51.

[24]Don Isaac Abravanel, Commentary on the Torah Genesis p. 346 (in the Jerusalem 5784 edition). 

[25]Ibid., p. 212.

[26]Ibid., 162–163. 

[27]OL, 439. 

[28]R. Samson Raphael Hirsch, Commentary on the Torah, Genesis 12:10. 

[29]Ibid., 25:37. 

[30]Ibid., 34:25–31.

[31]Ibid. 

[32]R. Naftali Zvi Yehuda Berlin, Ha'amek Davar, Genesis 24:65. 

[33]OL, 446. 

[34]R. Berlin, Harhev Davar, Genesis 27:1

[35]Ha'amek Davar, Genesis 38:15.

[36]OL, 445–446.

[37]R. Hayyim ibn Attar, Ohr ha-Hayyim, Genesis 45:4. 

[38]R. Meir Simha ha-Kohen, Meshekh Hokhma, Genesis 18:17. 

[39]R. Avigdor Nebenzahl, Sihot le-Sefer Bereishit, (Jerusalem 5750), 369–396. 

[40]Ibid., 387.

[41]R. Yosef Albo, Sefer ha-Ikkarim 4:26. 

[42]For analysis of this story and a list of traditional authorities who understand David's sin literally, see Amnon Bazak, II Samuel : David the King (Hebrew) (Jerusalem, 2013), 135–169.

[43]R. Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, Beit ha-Levi va-Yeshev, s.v. va-yasem sak be-matnav.

[44]R. David Kimhi Commentary on the Torah Genesis 37:34.

[45]R. Nosson Zvi Finkel, Ohr ha-Tzafun (Jerusalem, 5738), Part 1, 207–209.

[46]R. Hayyim Yaakov Goldvicht, Assufat Ma'arakhot Bereishit 2, 164. 

[47]R. Eliyahu Eliezer Dessler, Mikhtav me-Eliyahu (Jerusalem, 2002), Part 2, 175.

[48]Ibid., 228–229. 

[50]OL, 435.

[51]Ginsburg refers to R. Miller as "one of the gedolim" on page 34.  For a series of problematic statements from R. Miller, see my "The Hareidi Option," Conversations (Spring 2024), 75–90.

[52]On the history of Daas Torah, see Benjamin Brown, Democratization in the Haredi Leadership? The Doctrine of Da'at Torah at the Turn of the Twentieth and Twenty-First Centuries (Hebrew) (Jerusalem, 2011).

[54]There are several helpful articles on this topic in Hi Sihati: al Derekh Limmud ha-Tankah ed. Yehoshua Reiss (Jerusalem, 2013).

Rabbi Hayyim Angel's New Book: The Heart of Judges

We are thrilled to report that Rabbi Hayyim Angel has published the third volume of his new commentary on Tanakh: The Heart of Judges. Along with The Heart of the Five Megillot and The Heart of Joshua, it is available at amazon.com in paperback and Kindle formats.

This part of a project that ultimately will cover the entire Tanakh. Upcoming volumes currently in preparation are:

1 Samuel, 2 Samuel, 1 Kings, 2 Kings, Psalms, Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel.

The Heart of Tanakh series explores each biblical book through close textual analysis, classical Jewish commentary, and contemporary biblical scholarship. With the biblical text always at the center, each volume uncovers its literary artistry, historical setting, theological depth, and enduring religious and moral teachings. Written for both scholars and thoughtful general readers, the series shows how traditional learning and modern scholarship together illuminate the timeless message of Tanakh. Building on decades of teaching and writing, Rabbi Hayyim Angel offers a model of biblical interpretation in which rigorous scholarship and profound religious commitment work hand in hand, inviting readers to encounter the enduring voice of Tanakh with both intellectual honesty and spiritual depth.

 

You can order The Heart of Judges here:

https://www.amazon.com/s?k=heart+of+judges&crid=2XKM1MXDCHSCI&sprefix=%2Caps%2C132&ref=nb_sb_ss_recent_1_0_recent

Jewish Minds for Humankind: Newly Published Book by Rabbi Marc Angel

Jewish Minds for Humankind, by Rabbi Marc D. Angel, Da'at Press

 

Twenty-two figures. Twenty-two letters of the Hebrew alphabet. One argument: that a life rooted in Jewish tradition and open to the full breadth of human wisdom is the highest expression of both.
In this elegant collection, Rabbi Dr. Marc D. Angel profiles the thinkers, rabbis, poets, and activists who shaped his religious vision — from Rabbi Eliyahu Benamozegh in nineteenth-century Livorno to Primo Levi in the shadow of Auschwitz. Each essay recovers a mind that refused the false walls between the sacred and the secular, the particular and the universal, the ancient and the modern. Together they form a portrait of a Judaism deeply faithful and intellectually expansive — one that has always understood the love of God and the love of humanity as a single vocation.
For readers who believe that Jewish particularity and universal responsibility belong together, this book is both an inheritance and an invitation.

 

This book was originally published as issue 38 of Conversations, the journal of the Institute for Jewish Ideas and Ideals.

 

To order: https://www.daat.press/product-page/jewish-minds-for-humankind-rabbi-marc-angel

A Nation Under Restoration: Actualizing the Sepharadi Dream

 

 

The tragedies of the past few years for the Jewish nation have been immeasurable, yet they have forged a type of “national unity” that was previously thought to be impossible. More and more Jews around the globe are coming to terms with the fact that their lives are intimately tied up with those of their brethren, irrespective of each of their specific “versions” of Judaism—this in addition to their associations with the modern state of Israel. That is not to suggest that Jewish “infighting” is finished, or will be in the near future. However, this moment does present us with a rare opportunity in which to finally push toward actualizing the dream that Sepharadi Jews have hoped and advocated for since our exile two-thousand years ago: national reunification. However, to precisely understand this dream and how best to actualize it, it is crucial to first examine how Judaism has been historically understood by the Sepharadim.

Recent centuries in the west have led to Judaism receiving many labels, most notably “religion” and “ethnicity.” The former is often embodied by how modern-day Orthodoxy views Judaism, where one must “buy-in” to a set of dogmatic beliefs, or conform to the precise communal standards of law. The latter is best expressed by the diverse set of Jews who feel that while they have a “culture” that was ethnically passed down to them, it bears no relevance regarding God, covenant, or broader spiritual meaning. Yet, all these notions are foreign to the Sepharadim, who have consistently viewed Judaism the way it began—as a nation of people, bound together via a bilateral covenant that they formed with God at Sinai. It is not about someone’s dogmatic beliefs, or how they dress, or how precisely they observe the law; it is about whether they feel bound by the covenantal system that is in place. A fundamental aspect of that covenant is that it was freely contracted with the consent of the entire people: each member of Israel experienced a direct communication with God. As a result of this personalized experience, the collective people appointed Moshe to be their spokesman[1]—Moshe’s status as the lawgiver was not because of his miracles, his oratory skills, or his charisma, but because the people decided to approve him. Furthermore, the acceptance of the covenant did not take place during the moment of God’s theophany but was instead in a moment when God was not present amongst the people, thus allowing them to consider their decisions without divine coercion.[2] Due to the public nature of this covenant, no matter the person’s merits or abilities, each member of the Israelite nation is considered to be an active one, and is to be included in its system. Not only are they to be included, but each Israelite must be treated with the same basic standards of care and respect, for none are “above” each other within the covenantal system. The notion of citizenry eschews questions of “ethnicity,” “religiosity,” or familial background. It is thus unsurprising that Sepharadi legal authorities have never dismissed the works of their Ashkenazi brethren just based on their “ethnic origins” but have instead endeavored to study them based on the quality of their contents. Furthermore, the goal of expert jurists such as Rambam and R. Yosef Karo was to craft legal codes that would serve to educate the masses,[3] not just the elite scholars, and that would support the entire nation, not just a particular region of it.[4] R. Karo observed that the primary danger that faced the post-Spanish expulsion Jewish communities was not theological, but national. The people’s exilic fragmentations had made it difficult to coalesce back together as a nation which was bound by a unified legal system, 

 

For as the days lengthened for us, we have been poured from vessel to vessel and [have] walked into exile. Many afflictions, bundles of trouble, afflictions from here to there, have come upon us until, because of our sins, the verse was fulfilled, ‘the wisdom of its wise men shall perish’ (Isaiah 29:14). The hand of Torah and its students [has gone away] for the Torah has not been made into two Torot, but like Torot without count due to the great number of books which are [now] found – [all] explaining its judgements and laws [differently].[5]

 

With this view in mind, for the Sepharadim, exile (galut) was political, not “religious” or “spiritual”; it centered around the loss of national sovereignty[6] and the dispersal of its citizenry.[7] This national framework of Sepharadi Judaism leads to a far better understanding of how they reacted to questions of modernity and “secularization.” 

To the modern eye, Sepharadi Jews today stand as an “anomaly” —on the one hand they are deeply committed to traditional observance, but on the other hand, many are not “orthodox” or “strictly observant.” They have not splintered into denominations; no matter how “secularized” they have become, they will still gather for Shabbat and holiday services in the same traditional synagogues and perform the exact same traditional rituals with their families.[8] This phenomena has been, in my view, incorrectly assigned by most to the lack of an exposure to the “Enlightenment” and “Emancipation” movements in the Europe, which would have theoretically produced a more secular split amongst the Sepharadim as it did for the Ashkenazim. However, such a hypothesis fails on several fronts. First, many Sepharadi countries did become exposed to Enlightenment European thought via European colonialization, most notably via the Alliance Israélite Universelle, which went to North Africa, the Balkans, Iraq, etc.[9] These schools instructed children in the latest secular subjects, languages, and ideologies, with many becoming less adherent to the observant lifestyle. These schools were often sent with the mission of breaking the children away from traditional models. Yet, these communities never splintered, nor have their modern descendants, as “secular” as some of them are, broken away. Indeed, my own family, who came to America from Constantinople, is a perfect example of this “paradox”: upon their arrival, they took modern jobs, embraced modern educations and cultures, and did not observe a number of the legal requirements that their ancestors had observed. Yet, they continued to remain within the same communal structures, and traditional systems—to marry without the necessary halakhic requirements, or to go to a Reform temple was unthinkable.[10] Nor were these places lacking opportunities for emancipation: in Algeria for example, the Crémieux Decree granted its Jews full French citizenship, and many families from Iraq traveled and traded across Europe for their businesses.  Finally, several Sepharadi communities did exist within Europe, and yet when faced with the same challenges that led to the German reform movement, such as organs in the synagogue,[11] they did not devolve into factionalism when addressing them.[12] To me, this all points back to the national character of Sepharadi Judaism, which does not seek to impose views, or determine the “true culture,” which must serve as the communal standard, but instead seeks to include all its citizens in every way possible. Modernization brought with it numerous challenges for the Sepharadim, just as much as the Ashkenazim, but rather than respond to a perceived “theological” threat to the Jewish “religion,” the Sepharadim responded as any nation might—balance and integration when possible.

Moving beyond the general public, the Sepharadi sages were characterized by their extreme sensitivity to the people’s needs; they strove to guide them as best as possible while acknowledging that life and its circumstances are not always perfect. That is not to say that these figures were “happy” with breaches of the law, but they understood that persuasion and dialogue are stronger than a sword and fist. Better to keep someone within the fold than squeeze them out of it. Such respect for the public was reflected back onto them in turn, as the people acknowledged the scholarship and wisdom that they possessed. Halakha was treated as a living system of law, that required sensitivity, and that needed to be carefully applied to all the people, and not just the select few. The people understood that they were not always adhering to the laws as required, however that never meant viewing themselves as “not Jewish enough,” just as someone who chooses to speed past a red light in New York City would not view themselves as “less American.” Such a lifestyle recalls that of my parents. My parents are not the most observant Jews in the world. However, from my first conscious memory of life, I could feel their love of Judaism: They attended only traditional synagogues, stressed the importance of tefillin when I reached bar mitzvah, performed the Pesah seder with joy, and instilled a deep, intuitive, belief that God exists and has a relationship with each of us. Those whom they knew with higher observance standards were not the subject of ridicule or rejection, but of admiration and respect. They did not have to keep every detail of kashrut or Shabbat for me to understand that Judaism is meaningful, and that Jewish law is important even if it is not always kept. For them, “alternative” Judaisms are completely unthinkable—how does one even begin to replace their national system?

Such a national character is also found within the writings of key Sepharadi figures during the emergence of the State of Israel.[13] One might have expected them to focus on the spiritual greatness of such an achievement, or the pollution of it by the “secular Zionists,” however none of this was their focus. Instead, the dream of the modern state was best expressed by R. Ben-Tzion Meir Hai Uziel, 

 

the national mission [of the state], which is the central bar that connects, joins, and binds, all the limbs of the nation into a single body, must be intellectually recognized and clarified to those who stand at the head of the nation’s leadership, and to every one of its members…the slogan of the assimilators or fake-philosophers, ‘be a Jew in your home [but] a human in your streets’, is absurd and foolish…hiding this mission in the synagogue or study hall, or even the private rooms of our homes and neighborhoods, is to conceal and bury our national mission. Those who hide their Judaism in [secret] rooms so that no strange eye may see it…reveal about themselves that they do not know what it is, or the [real] value of Judaism.[14] 

 

The restoration of a state would allow for the national character of Judaism to flourish once more, expanding back out from the ritual halls into the civilian streets, and working on a national level. In speaking of the role of Jewish law within the new state, R. Uziel stressed that it must be of a national character:

 

it is my tremendous desire to unify all of the divisions that the diaspora tore us into, the separate communities of Sepharadim, Ashkenazim, Teimanim, etc. This will not be a difficult task for me, since unity is in our nature and our national character as a people. It was only our dispersion throughout the diaspora that created the particular linguistic and communal divisions that exist amongst us. As we now return to our homeland, there is absolutely no reason to continue living by these communal and linguistic divisions imported from the diaspora. Instead, we will be one unified community.[15]

 

Questions of ethnicity or particular practice in law become irrelevant, all that matters is the unification of the nation. To these figures, the modern State of Israel represents a divinely gifted chance for reunification, and for the national salvation of Israel and its people. Such a reunification is primarily expressed through the restoration of Israel’s legal courts of halakha, and through the communal life of the national citizenry. Of course, the exile has been long and difficult, it is therefore understandable that a reunification would be fraught with challenges in how to get all the citizens back under the same framework once again, both “secular” and “religious.”

From the inception of the State of Israel, these Sepharadi thinkers pondered this very question: how to best encourage and promote such a process, especially for those who were not actively observing the laws. However, the overarching answer remained the same as it had been in antiquity: persuasion. R. Uziel was once asked by a worker’s union about a milkman who was making deliveries on Shabbat as he would during the weekdays. This posed an issue for his membership in the union, which explicitly stipulated that it would not allow a Shabbat desecrator to be a member. The question was whether to label this man as a Shabbat desecrator and thereby remove him. R. Uziel responded as follows, 

 

I was hesitant in this matter, because on the one hand the prohibition stands before our sages that, “one should always push away [a person] with their left hand and bring them closer with their right hand” (Sotah 47a), but on the other hand I was concerned that perhaps [the public] would say, “the Pharisees permitted the matter” (Sanhedrin 82b)…and if you are silent and continue on in silence, this will be considered in the public eye as if you permitted the matter…however, I decided to judge this man favorably because he did not know there was a prohibition in his actions. Therefore, I must inform him of all that I wrote and to reprove him with pleasant words regarding his weak [observance], which is wrapped up in his weaker belief regarding the sanctity of Shabbat, that [he does not feel that God] provides for all who keep Shabbat according to the law…and I am assured that these [pleasant] words will enter his heart, sit there, and heal him as it is said, “peace, peace for those far and for those near said God, and I will heal them.” (Isaiah 57:19)[16] 

 

Encouraging adherence to the law, and educating the people in its importance, did not equal their exclusion or persecution. R. Hayyim David Halevy, R. Uziel’s prime student and spiritual successor, was once asked whether Judaism is compatible with the values of a democracy. His answer was extremely nuanced; he at once rejected that the two were equivalent. This is reflective of a historical truth, that Judaism’s system, which includes a monarchy, and does not grant every specific citizen a vote in its affairs, does not match a modern democracy. Nevertheless, R. Halevy intuitively noted to the questioner, that much like a modern democracy, Judaism does not impose itself upon its citizens. Even during the Second Temple Era, when Israel wielded far more power, including corporal punishments, the government refused to enforce them with prejudice against the people—this in spite of the fact that not everyone was adherent to all the laws.[17] Thus, R. Halevy notes that, “there was not, nor will there be, any ability to force Torah and mitzvot on the group…but in our time, any attempt to force [these spiritual] views and beliefs onto others with force and violence awaits a great danger, a danger to deepen the chasms of hatred between the parts of the nation.”[18] It is only through successfully demonstrating that Judaism is a livable, sensitive, communal system, free of coercion, that the people will fully return—this national, and inclusive, view is what was always responsible for Sepharadi unity and traditional adherence from its members.

Returning to the present, our nation would do well to heed these messages of our ancestors. Judaism must not dissipate into just another culture of the past, but it also cannot shrink into a small group of intentionally pious figures and their followers. Judaism must retain its national character, and its leaders and sages must look toward addressing the needs of not just those who choose to scrupulously fulfill the law, but also to those who do no such thing. In this fashion, the Chabad movement has already tapped into something wonderful—their simple encouragement to perform actions and participate in events, regardless of one’s background or belief has allowed for countless Jews to retain a connection to the national covenant, and feel more welcomed in spiritual participation. But this cannot remain an isolated phenomenon, nor can the flames of unity, which current global events have sparked be stamped out so quickly. It is easy to fall back into factionalism, and to promote leaders who incite division between families, neighbors, and the overall nation. The visions of Rabbis Halevy, Uziel, Karo, Rambam, and the Talmudic sages themselves, must not be cast aside in this crucial hour. The collapse of Israel in the Second Temple was not from a lack of ritual stringency, or a failure to stamp out heretics and rebellious individuals—it was from political corruption,[19] a complete lack of unity and comradery,[20] and a failure to understand that the Jewish nation is first and foremost a nation that serves all its citizens. This is as the Talmudic sages teach regarding the four species on Sukkot, that even the “simplest” Jew must be bound together with the “wisest” in national participation. Our leaders must be held accountable for their rhetoric, and they must be reminded of their national mission; they cannot be allowed to cater only to the groups that currently uplift them. They must recognize the opportunities of the present in strengthening this goal, rather than actively weakening it. Those who carry legal influence must be reminded that their responsibility is not just to the pious few who will obey their every detail of law, but also to the masses who seek a livable system in their daily lives. Finally, the general public must be made aware of this national goal via education that stresses such a mindset and actively works to bridge people rather than further separate them. What made the Sinaitic experience so unique was not simply that everyone participated, but that each individual personally experienced it. No person turned toward their fellows to coercively impose what they had experienced. Each separate person experienced God together. May our people soon achieve this not just for a moment in the desert, but for an eternity in Israel.

 


 


[1] Exodus 20:16.

[2] Exodus 24:3.

[3] See the introduction to both the Mishneh Torah and the Shulhan Arukh.

[4] In contrast to the plethora of Ashkenazic glosses that are written onto texts, such as those of R. Moses Isserles, which aim to directly correct the texts toward the particular “ethnic” region, Sepharadi jurists tend to offer these as separate works from the national codes. 

[5] Introduction to Bet Yosef. This problem is supported by current data suggesting the existence of dozens of smaller congregations in places such as Constantinople during this time, each refusing to integrate with the others for fear of losing their particular practices. (see Rabbi Dr. H. J. Zimmels, Ashkenazim and Sephardim: Their Relations, Differences, and Problems as Reflected in the Rabbinical Responsa, K’tav Publishing House, Hoboken, NJ 1996 pg. 44).

[6] Hence why the messianic redemption is associated with national sovereignty being restored above all else (see Mishneh Torah Laws of Kings and Wars 12).

[7] “The Israelite nation was scattered, becoming further dispersed amidst all the lands, arriving at its borders and distant islands. Quarrels increased in the world, and paths of travel became fraught with soldiers…” (Introduction to Mishneh Torah).

[8] My wife and I once visiting some of her relatives in Ashkelon for Rosh HaShanah and running into their building manager who appeared in plainclothes and without a kippah. Yet later that day I noticed him in the corner of the Sepharadi synagogue, draped in his tallit, head bent in intense prayer, without a moment of interruption. 

[9] “[H]undreds of thousands of North African Jews, whose families had learned French long before their counterparts in Poland had learned Polish, and olim (immigrants) from sophisticated Iraqi and Egyptian Jewish communities – not to speak of the Judesmo-speaking Jews of the Balkans who were as involved in European culture as any Jews in the world – were lumped together [by racist thinkers] with the most unsophisticated cave dwellers.” Daniel J. Elazar, The Other Jews: The Sephardim Today, Basic Books inc., New York, 1989, pg. 9.

[10] Notably, their eventual loss of connection came when marrying into Ashkenazic families who took a very different approach to denominations and beliefs.

[11] For a concise presentation on the balanced approach that Sepharadi authorities took in addressing these European synagogue updates, see Rabbi Dr. José Faur, Sephardim in the Nineteenth Century: New Directions and Old Values, in Proceedings of the American Academy for Jewish Research, vol. 44 (1977), pg. 29-52.

[12] This should not imply that the further “east” communities did not also face questions of halakha within modern life. Iraqi communities dealt with water pumping factories for a mikveh, train rides on Shabbat, carrying European fashion-parasols without an eruv, etc. For a presentation of these issues throughout the eastern Sepharadi world, see Zvi Zohar, Rabbinic Creativity in the Modern Middle East, Bloomsbury Academic Press, 2013.

[13] It must be noted that concern for the restoration of the national government was central for Sepharadi figures such as R. Yehuda Alkalai, even before figures such as Herzl emerged. Before Ben Yehuda “famously” restored the Hebrew language, such a task was being encouraged by Sepharadi women such as Abigail Abarbanel Lindo. 

[14] Hegyonei Uziel 25:3.

[15] Mikhmanei Uziel, Volume 1, 325, English translation by Rabbi Daniel Bouskila.

[16] Aseh Lekha Rav Vol. 8, page 313.

[17] For example, one who studies Talmudic literature will find numerous conversations regarding individuals who are not to be trusted regarding laws of ritual purity; however, the sages strove to find ways in which the more scrupulous could still eat alongside them (see Mishneh Torah Ritual Impurity of Foods 16:11). 

[18] Aseh Lekha Rav, Vol. 8, pg. 282.

[19] See Bava Metzia 30b and Gittin 55b-56a.

[20] See Yoma 9b and Shabbat 119b.