National Scholar Updates

How B’nai Mitzvah Options for People with Disabilities Can Expand Our Thinking About Marking this Rite of Passage More Meaningfully for Everyone

 

The B’nai Mitzvah “Minimum”

 

As a social worker, special education teacher and disabilities inclusion specialist in the Jewish community, I receive many calls each year from parents of children with disabilities who worry their children will not be able to “get” bar or bat mitzvah-ed. Perhaps they are not members of a synagogue and have no idea how to meaningfully mark this rite of passage. Or, if they are members of a synagogue, they are aware of the high bar of expectations which may involve reading from the Torah, chanting the Haftarah, leading the congregation in prayer, and delivering a devar Torah. They “know” their children can’t do these things and wonder if there might be other options. As they are about to give up, they call for guidance.

The first thing I do is validate their concerns and frustrations—and suggest they discuss it with their rabbi. I then reassure them that their son will become bar mitzvah automatically when they turn 13 years, and their daughters will become bat mitzvah in the same way at age 12. I explain that bar mitzvah is not a verb and that their child won’t “get” or even “have” a bar mitzvah. To further make my point, I playfully take it to the “absurd” and explain that their child’s status will change from Jewish child to adult even if they stay in their pajamas, under the covers, on the day they turn 13 on the Hebrew calendar.

Families are incredulous at first. They (usually fathers) reflect on their own experience of preparing for and marking becoming a bar mitzvah—which is oftentimes not a positive memory. They are convinced that their child needs to publicly recite the Torah blessings, read from the Torah and chant the Haftarah; otherwise, “it doesn’t count.”

If they still don’t believe me, I bring forth the example of girls.  I remind them that, not too long ago, women didn’t celebrate becoming bat mitzvah, yet they somehow managed to became Jewish adults. 

Once they finally buy in to the fact that the status changes automatically, I begin a conversation about creative synagogue options they may have never witnessed before. I encourage them to dream of ways to mark their child’s special day in a way which is meaningful, special and appropriate—whether they are a person with autism, anxiety and other mental health issues, visual impairments, deafness, are non-speakers or have minimal speech, mobility issues, or deal with learning disabilities. 

I encourage them to think about the many options available. There are non-Shabbat morning and non-synagogue options which include making the bar/bat mitzvah on other days of the week, conducting the ceremony at a Jewish summer camp, in a restaurant or in one’s own backyard.

Our new book, A DIFFERENT SPIRIT: Creating Meaningful B’nai Mitzvah for Children with Disabilities, edited by myself and Ilana Trachtman—the filmmaker who told the story of the bar mitzvah of Lior, a young man with Down Syndrome in her 2008 award-winning film, “Praying with Lior”—includes a range of contributors including clergy, educators, psychologists and people with disabilities (among them a deaf rabbi and an autistic professor of special education). It is designed to help clergy and families navigate creating meaningful and inclusive celebration for everyone. 

The book’s chapters and essays include inspiration and practical guidance on planning celebrations, managing accommodations and settings, and teaching children with a wide range of disabilities, as well as personal stories and an exploration of the concept of inclusion.

 

Beyond the “Standard” Shabbat Morning B’nai Mitzvah 

 

One reason most families of children with disabilities cannot imagine their child marking becoming b’nai mitzvah at all is that they have only seen or attended b’nai mitzvah which take place on Shabbat (Saturday) mornings, in the context of a service which is long, formal, packed with attendees and where the bar or bat mitzvah student is expected to “do” a lot of the service.

In most synagogues, the student is expected to learn the complete Haftarah or selections from the Haftarah (weekly prophetic portion), prepare one or several aliyot from the weekly parashah[ja1]  (Torah reading) which will be chanted from the scroll (with no vowels, punctation or musical notes) on the actual day, lead parts of the service and write and publicly deliver a devar Torah. Young women may prepare to read Torah in a woman’s tefillah group, though they more commonly mark their becoming bat mitzvah by learning a text or subject in depth and preparing a devar Torah or conducting a siyyum (celebratory conclusion) of a biblical or rabbinic book.

This process of preparation is rigorous and challenging for many learners—especially those with a wide range of learning challenges.  

For those learning to read Torah, the teacher usually begins by teaching the system of biblical cantillation or “trope,” which requires learning a system of musical notation. In general, the key to successful Torah reading is good auditory and visual memories and the ability to decode Hebrew. For students with deficits in any or all of these areas, the learning process can be very challenging.  

Even for those who master the learning, public performance—especially in front of a large crowd on a Saturday morning—can also be challenging and intimidating.

 

Non-Shabbat Morning B’nai Mitzvah Options, Why They Aren’t Offered More Often, and the Issue of Equality versus Equity

 

Synagogues may have understandable reasons for only offering b’nai mitzvah on Saturday mornings. In many communities, this is the big day or only day for the community to come together.  

Some synagogues offer a Shabbat afternoon and havdalah service—which is a relatively short service featuring three short torah readings. While marking b’nai mitzvah at this much shorter, less formal service may be a good option for some learners, some synagogues worry that it is not “fair” to offer this option as this would mean that these students would prepare much less than those celebrating b’nai mitzvah on Shabbat morning.

This raises an important issue of equality versus equity. While it may seem admirable to treat everyone equally or “the same” when it comes to setting expectations for b’nai mitzvah, equity means treating people differently based on their specific needs and circumstances.  Equality assumes everyone starts at the same place and equity acknowledges individual differences. B’nai mitzvah options should reflect differences among learners.

Other less stressful, non-Shabbat options for marking bar or bat mitzvah include Mondays and Thursdays (days when the Torah is traditionally read), Rosh Hodesh (the new Jewish month), or holidays (Hanukkah, the middle days of Sukkot, Purim, etc).  All of these options also allow for the use of technology (microphones, Power Point, Dynavox augmented speech) and musical accompaniment as there are no Sabbath-observance restrictions on using electronics on these days. 

In my 40-plus years of working with families to find suitable options and preparing students and in many cases, officiating such services, and in a lifetime of visiting synagogues of all sizes and denominations around the world, I have seen many creative solutions that were “just right” for each student and family. 

Max, a minimally verbal student with autism, marked his bar mitzvah on the Sunday of Sukkot. He did not recite Torah blessings, but spent the service on the bimah, next to the cantor, banging out rhythms on a drum. He was very comfortably dressed in clothes which did not upset his sensory issues. A very small brunch followed in his New York City apartment.

Adam celebrated his bar mitzvah on the Sunday of Hanukkah. The rabbi wisely pointed out that the Torah reading for that day follows a repetitive and predictive pattern; once Adam learned “the pattern,” he was able to master the entire Torah reading. A festive brunch followed in the synagogue.

Ruby did not want to mark his bar mitzvah on Shabbat morning in his synagogue. He eventually agreed to read the maftir, the final three lines of the Torah reading. Not having to face the congregation was a big help. He refused to deliver a devar Torah as this was too “scary.” Instead, he was happy to push “play” on the computer at the Sunday brunch reception, where guests were treated to a very thoughtful 10-minute pre-recorded devar Torah.

I have worked with several students who celebrated bar or bat mitzvah on Purim evening—they were able to learn a few verses of the Purim megillah (scroll) which they recited in costume, with all guests clad in costumes as well—this helped keep the day relaxed and festive.

Many years ago, I attended morning minyan in a Manhattan shul on a Thursday morning. A 13-year-old boy and his father, new immigrants from Russia and not well-versed in Hebrew, prayers or traditional Jewish practice, came to minyan. The boy was called to the Torah to recite the blessings before and after the reading of the third Torah aliyah. The rabbi congratulated him on becoming bar mitzvah. None of the regular minyan goers were expecting to attend a bar mitzvah and therefore did not have candy for showering the boy with their warm wishes—they simply congratulated him with the singing of “Siman Tov u’Mazal Tov.”

 

Beyond Alternative Days and Dates: Alternative Venues, Service Formats and Non-Service B’nai Mitzvah

 

Some synagogues are sensitive to just how intimidating the “big shul” can be for some students and may offer a chapel bar/bat mitzvah or, in “extreme cases,” a rabbi’s study bar or bat mitzvah. Many years ago, Corey marked his bar mitzvah with his divorced parents, the rabbi and me in the rabbi’s study. Corey had mental health and behavioral issues, and this was the right venue; while it would not accord with the traditional practice of being called to the Torah in the presence of a minyan, it was the perfect option in his situation.

For other families, out of synagogue b’nai mitzvahs are the best option. They include one’s backyard, a beach or country house, a small conference room at a hotel, restaurant, or out in nature.

Our book shares the story of Lisa, a Jewish Day School student with learning disabilities and anxiety and amazing artistic ability. Lisa marked her becoming a bat mitzvah literally without saying a word. 

Lisa spent the year leading up to bat mitzvah studying Jewish texts and illustrating and painting scenes of scenes which she found meaningful. Her art served as interpretation and commentary of her understanding of these stories. The bat mitzvah—held in an art gallery—was an opportunity for her guests to view her art and read her explanations while sipping wine and eating d’oeuvres.

There is an entire chapter in the book “By a Lake or in a Tree: Celebrating in a Camp Setting” which shares the how’s and why’s of holding b’nai mitzvah at a summer camp. This relaxed, outdoor option is perfect for some students and families.

I worked with a family who made b’nai mitzvah for triplets at their beach house—close to where the mother and father spent their childhood summers. Another family rented a Torah and marked their only child’s bar mitzvah in the living room of their large Manhattan apartment, overlooking Central Park. Another family used the large outdoor property of their country house in Western Massachusetts.

 

More About Why “A Different Spirit” May Be Useful in Creating Meaningful B’nai Mitzvah for Children with Disabilities

 

When Ilana and I set out to write our book, we imagined a book for families, clergy and teachers which would offer guidance on how to navigate creating meaningful and inclusive celebrations for everyone.  The book would provide inspiring essays and practical guidance on planning celebrations, managing accommodations and teaching children with a range of support needs.

The first two essays demonstrate how inclusion elevates and creates a sense of belonging, and how b’nai mitzvah affirms the essential tenet of Judaism of being created in God’s image.

Part I, which has 10 chapters, looks at creating inclusive communities, building supports along the journey, dreaming and imagining and planning, the role of siblings, an essay on invoking the arts in the b’nai mitzvah process, b’nai mitzvah in summer camps, and a very thoughtful dialogue on if/when b’nai mitzvah should be off the table. 

Part II offers specific tools to teachers including multi-sensory approaches to teaching Hebrew, using Braille, and teaching students who are deaf and hard of hearing. These latter two chapters are written by people with disabilities including a bat mitzvah student who is blind (along with her mother who is a clergy member), and a chapter by a deaf rabbi and his hearing sister. There are also chapters on learning disabilities and mental health challenges and references to speech impairments and mobility challenges. An essay in this section, “What if I bark on the bimah?” is by Jewish educator and comedian Paula Schuller. She speaks openly and with humor about having Tourette’s Syndrome. 

 

A Final Word: Why A Book About B’nai Mitzvah and Disabilities Just Might Revolutionize B’nai Mitzvah for EVERYONE!

 

The intended audience for our book is the Jewish disabilities community. Perhaps somewhat surprisingly, members of other faith communities are finding the book useful—while life cycle events vary, the issues faced by people with disabilities in houses of worship are similar.

We are also finding that parents of non-disabled students are excited that there may be options for marking b’nai mitzvah that they had not considered in the past.  Perhaps a less stressful, non-Shabbat morning, outdoor bat mitzvah in nature is just right for their daughter?!

We are all familiar with the history of curb cuts on public sidewalks. They were initially intended for users of wheelchairs and other mobility assist devices. Once the curb cuts were built, parents with strollers and delivery people with carts found them to be useful as well. So with “non-traditional” b’nai mitzvah.

We hope and pray that synagogues and temples will begin by offering non-Shabbat b’nai mitzvahs to students with disabilities, and that they will see the benefit of this offering for all students. Some families will favor Shabbat morning in the main synagogue; others will enjoy Havdalah in the chapel and others will love the Monday, Thursday, Rosh Hodesh or holiday option. There is no downside, since, after all, everyone becomes b’nai mitzvah regardless of what they do to mark it and when they choose to mark it!

 

 


 [ja1]Italicize?

You Will be Defined. The Question Is: By Whom?

 

I grew up in Tampa, Florida. It is a wonderful place. I was raised in a secular family with a strong sense of Jewish identity, but I did not understand what that identity meant or why being Jewish was something distinct. From a young age, my public-school classmates told me, “You’re not white. You’re Jewish.” I didn’t quite grasp this. It created a sense of otherness, but it also felt like something special, even precious. While I thought I looked like most of my classmates, they saw something else. There were not many of us Jewish students, and we were all told the same thing, very matter of factly. It was simply accepted, along with whatever difference it meant to be Jewish.

As Rabbi Jonathan Sacks observed, if you do not define your identity, others will define it for you and not always kindly. My experience at the time was benign and I did not yet appreciate what being Jewish meant, but the world had already begun to tell me. 

Before I came to understand Judaism, I came to antisemitism. I learned how Jews were seen long before I understood who Jews were. That is not a stable way to build identity. It would be many years before I began to internalize what it means to be Jewish and observe our practices. I remember hearing phrases like “Jewish values,” but I did not know what those values were. I was fortunate to have strong history teachers, and we learned about World War II and the Holocaust, but I had no real sense of the thousands of years that came before. Years later, I encountered Tanakh, tefillot, and mitzvot, along with the teachings of Rabbi Sacks and other giants. I began to see the difference between an identity shaped by others’ hatred and one rooted in knowledge, practice, a tradition of strength, and most importantly a connection with HaShem.

Rabbi Jonathan Sacks warned that Jews would be defined by others whether they chose it or not. This has been the pattern for centuries. Antisemitism has taken many forms, a dynamic hatred that adapts to the weaknesses of each society in which it takes hold. The writer Vasily Grossman, who witnessed both Nazi and Soviet brutality, understood something essential about antisemitism. It is not simply hatred of Jews. It reveals something about the society that produces it and the individuals who perpetuate it.

It often presents itself in acceptable, even noble terms, cloaking hostility in the language of morality, whether as opposition to a religion, a race, or, as we see today, a country in the popular form of anti-Zionism. It is all too easy for a sacred religious identity to become defined in response to hatred, rather than grounded in its own inheritance. When those who hate you define you, the result is an unstable and uncertain identity. It pulls you away from the stable foundation laid millennia before and fills the space of faith and practice.

I thought I could recognize propaganda. I thought it was something obvious, something you could spot and reject. But over time I came to see that it is often far more subtle. It does not always announce itself. It adapts. It shifts language. And when it comes to Jews, it has done this for centuries. Antisemitism has followed a familiar pattern throughout history. Whatever a society fears or resents, Jews are blamed. This is why the accusations can be contradictory. Jews are cast as outsiders and, at the same time, as wielding hidden influence. Too weak and too powerful. The claims do not need to make sense. They only need to serve a purpose. When identity is shaped in response to those claims, it becomes unstable and uncertain, dependent on those who deny your place and, at times, your right to exist. The contradictions do not cancel each other out. They coexist. That is part of the point. I experienced this firsthand recently.

I ran for the Teaneck Board of Education this past fall. It was an all-consuming experience for myself and my family. My running mate and I ran on a platform of accountability, community, and excellence and we ran a campaign of integrity. We expected a tough race. What we did not expect was the level of personal attack. There were six candidates. I was the only one identified by religion. I was labeled a “Jewish activist.”  While I don’t object to the term, it was not how I would describe myself. More importantly, it immediately marked me as different. Throughout the campaign, I encountered a familiar contradiction: I was cast simultaneously as an outsider and as someone connected to powerful groups exercising insider control. My running mate, who is not Jewish, was also targeted. He was portrayed as having compromised himself by aligning with the Jews.

This is part of the power of antisemitism. Some dismiss it as politics, a dirty sport if there ever was one. But these attacks went beyond policy or disagreement. They became personal and drew on popular tropes. On election day, a box truck drove through town with a large screen displaying the message “Stop the non-public school takeover.” The message reduced complex public issues to a simple threat and the messaging was effective. I did not win, though the race was close. My running mate came even closer. I accept the result. What I do not accept are methods that moved beyond policy and into something more personal and troubling.

The challenges we face today are new in form but familiar in substance. The language and setting change, but the pattern remains. A grounded Jewish identity, shaped by our sacred texts, faith, practices, and history, and strengthened by our families and communities, provides stability where none exists in the accusations of others. It is not a shield against hatred, but it allows us to withstand it without being defined or destroyed by it. That kind of identity does not emerge on its own. It must be taught, learned, and lived. It is the responsibility of each individual to embody it with gratitude and strength, of parents to teach it to their children, and of each generation to pass it on. 

Responsiveness as a Greatmaking Property

When we talk about “God,” we intuitively think of a powerful, nonphysical entity that somehow created and runs the universe. To clarify this vague conception and set a more concrete groundwork for discussions about the nature of God, classical theologians have posited the Greatest Possible Being (GPB) thesis as the primary mode of understanding God.[i]After expounding upon the definition and implications of the GPB construct, this article will argue that a GPB identifiable as the God of religious tradition by said definition will contain responsiveness as one of its attributes rather than complete immutability as the Greeks and other classical theologians have posited.

The GPB concept requires both an intuitive and a more robust definition. Intuitively, the term “greatest possible being” accurately portrays God as “the being than which none greater can be conceived.”[ii] If one can conceive of a being greater than the working conception of the GPB, then the conception is wrong. Augustine explains the experience of thinking about a GPB conception of God as one where “one’s thought strains to reach something than which there is nothing higher or more sublime.”[iii] Experientially, in the process of thinking about God, the human intellect reaches its limits; Adams asserts that “Divine nature is permanently partially beyond our cognitive grasp” when grappling with the GPB.[iv]

The concept still needs a robust definition to make it comprehensible. Morris provides a clear framework of how one would construct a maximally perfect being a priori by explaining that “God is thought of as exemplifying necessarily a maximally perfect set of compossible greatmaking properties.”[v] Morris defines perfections as “Properties which are constituted by the logical maximum of an upwardly bounded, degreed great-making property,” which are “Properties it is intrinsically better to have than to lack.”[vi] These properties must also have a theoretical limit that can be maxed out for the GPB. For example, God can know everything, but God cannot be infinitely rich; therefore, knowledge is a greatmaking property and wealth is not. The maximally perfect set of these properties thus has room for flexibility; people can disagree about which properties are optimal for God to have while still agreeing on the general GPB framework.

There are two different approaches to a God that can both lead to the belief in a GPB. Morris outlines an a priorist tradition, which “begins with a purportedly self-evident conception of God as the greatest possible being” and uses this “exalted yet simple conception of deity to entail all the divine attributes.”[vii] An Anselmian theologian could construct a GPB without ever leaving the ivory tower. In contrast, an a posteriorist approach builds from empirical and experiential facts to a conception of God. Morris argues that rather than “contrast[ing] starkly the God of faith with the God of reason, the God of history with the God of the academy, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob with the God of the philosophers,” we can argue that these are one and the same.[viii] Because the GPB is a “proper object of religious devotion” due to its maximal perfection, religious individuals can certainly worship such a being.[ix]

The hinge of this claim that the GPB is the God of religious traditions is that the GPB is worthy of our worship. If our notion of God was only pretty good, and the possibility of a GPB existed, then it would not be logical to worship the PDGB (Pretty Darn Good Being).[x] However, if “we know that if there is a highest one, it deserves our fealty, not arbitrarily, but because of its perfections.”[xi] This move not only allows the GPB to be the God of religious traditions, but even more so argues that the GPB is the best candidate for the job.

With this in mind, I would like to shift to one specific greatmaking property, immutability, and analyze whether it belongs in the maximally perfect set of greatmaking properties, which belong to a GPB that is also the God of religious traditions. Morris asserts that “traditionally, the Anselmian description has been understood to entail that God is, among other things, omnipotent, immutable, eternal...”.[xii] Immutability is certainly a greatmaking property by definition; the question is if a GPB would possess this property or its competitor, responsiveness, in its maximally perfect set. Despite the philosophical tradition in favor of divine immutability, rejecting immutability would not pose a problem to Anselmian GPB construction. “The specific properties an Anselmian God must have are under-determined by the Anselmian formula and by the basic intuitions by means of which it is applied.”[xiii] So long as we can assert that responsiveness is preferable to immutability for religious observance or that immutability is not coherent, we can still uphold Morris’s claim that the GPB is the God of religion.

We must first analyze arguments for immutability to better understand its definition and implications. Relying on God’s assertion to Moses that God’s name is “I will be that which I shall be,”[xiv] Augustine argues that “a God who gave His very name as “I am” and is perfect must be the perfect case of being. But what can change is not a perfect case of being: it does not have its being so securely that it cannot cease to be what it is.”[xv] Since the perfect form of being is immutability, God, who engages in this process of being, must do so in a perfect way, and therefore is immutable. Boethius argues for divine timelessness along similar lines: “Temporal beings no longer live the past parts of their lives. They do not yet live the future parts of their lives.”[xvi] Under the premise that these are both defects, God must have “no past or future. What has no past or future does not change.”[xvii] Classical philosophers thus believe God cannot change for better or for worse because even improving is an imperfection in the state of being for these philosophers.

Such assertions are validated in the Jewish tradition as well. Malachi quotes a prophecy from God in which God asserts; “I am the LORD; I have not changed.”[xviii] Maimonides hones in on this verse in his Guide for the Perplexed, where he asserts that “[God] is immutable in every respect, as He expressly declares, ‘I, the Lord, do not change;’ i.e., in Me there is not any change whatever.”[xix] Similarly, Rabbi Abraham ibn Ezra responds harshly when the Bible says that “God renounced the punishment God had planned to bring upon God’s people” following the sin of the Golden Calf, which seems to imply that God changed God’s mind about the punishment.[xx] Ibn Ezra emphatically declares “God forbid that Hashem should repent! No, the Torah is merely speaking in a language that human beings can understand!”[xxi] Clearly, the intuitive objection against divine mutability of any form influenced some of the greatest biblical commentators.

However, despite the tradition in favor of Divine immutability, there are several philosophical objections to divine immutability, including that of Norman Kretzmann:

 

  1. If God is omniscient, God knows what time it is now.
  2. What time it is now is constantly changing.
  3. What God knows is constantly changing. (First, He knows that it is now t and not now t+1; later He knows that it is now t+1 and not now t.)
  4. God is constantly changing.[xxii]

 

The primary objection to this is that God does not need to know directly what time it is now; rather, the timeless God knows what humans know the present time to be, at all times. The discussion on this objection extends far beyond the scope of the paper, but it introduces complexity into the concept of immutability from a purely philosophical standpoint without even invoking religious experience.

However, the most important objection to immutability and argument in favor of responsiveness is that a robust religious tradition which believes in a human’s ability to have a dynamic relationship with God must allow for modifications to Divine immutability. This need not reject all forms of immutability. One can argue that God possesses time-indexed attributes, that it is always true that at time X God does Y. But this does necessarily reject the Augustinian and Maimonidean notion of perfect being as described above, which refuses to allow God to change at all. Thus, “responsiveness” could be comprised of preordained responses of an immutable God rather than pure reactions to events as open theism posits.[xxiii] Either way, responsiveness means that God’s behaviors and actions can vary over time (even if God is not intrinsically changing). Being in a dynamic, loving relationship demands that God’s actions change over time in accordance with a person’s actions and state of mind. It could be preordained in that since God has foreknowledge of a person’s actions and states of mind, God could eternally have time-indexed responses to each person.[xxiv] However, these specific actions are always tailored to respond to the person in his/her present state.[xxv]

Responsiveness also has a place in religious traditions. The Bible raises several cases where God regrets a decision or changes God’s mind. For example, in Genesis, God “regrets that God created humankind.”[xxvi] God’s attitude toward humanity seems to change in response to humanity’s free choice to sin. The Akeidat Yitzhak, a fifteenth-century Spanish rabbi, explains that Divine regret

 

is a re-consideration of one's plans and attitudes based on a changed set of circumstances … it is an admission that one had erred in one's assessment of the facts which one's promise had been based on. A changed attitude then becomes an act of wisdom, a rejection of foolishness.[xxvii]

 

Of course, this is not to imply that God erred in original judgment and plan. Rather, “when the Bible describes God as having reconsidered, it tells us that God continued to desire that He could carry out what He had originally planned, but what had now become impossible due to the conduct of the other half of the partnership between God and Man.”[xxviii] The preservation of free will demands a God who can change God’s attitudes and actions in response to human choices. Thus, the language of regret can still apply to God, who is “saddened” in having to resort to the alternative plan even though God knew it would happen all along. As such, we can still preserve a perfect but responsive God at all moments in time: when the circumstances change, the most perfect God responds perfectly to those changes to remain perfect for each specific moment.

Similarly, Rabbi Nachman of Bratslav uses this verse to argue that God feels emotion, so to speak, in response to human actions.[xxix] He writes that “We find, therefore, that if there is any misfortune or harsh decree affecting [the world], then certainly the joy of the Holy One is lessened, as in, ‘He grieved in His heart.’26 As the Sages taught: When a person sins, what does the Shekhinah [God] say? ‘My head is heavy! My arms are heavy!”’[xxx] The notion of a responsive God provides a model for religious experience where God deeply cares about our actions, rejoicing in our successes and lamenting our failures.

This concept of a responsive, dynamic God allows for some of the most important elements of religion, including Divine action and a personal God. For God to act in history, this requires that God not act the same way in all times, implying that God acts in relation to the world in a time-dependent manner, either through actual mutability or time-indexed immutability. William Mann provides an example from the Ten Plagues in Exodus: At time t1, God willed that there be locusts in Egypt; at time t2, God willed that there be neither locusts nor darkness; and at time t3, God willed that there be darkness.[xxxi] Such a proposition contradicts the Augustinian notion of divine immutability, which would claim that God is timeless and remains the same at all times. Yet, for religions that believe that God intervenes in a temporal world and speaks to temporal beings, they must concede this point. Even more powerful is the notion of a personal God. The Old Testament emphasizes how God has a close relationship with each person. Performing good deeds strengthens one’s connection to God, sinning weakens it.[xxxii] The Bible asserts that God provides reward and punishment commensurate with one’s actions;[xxxiii] that God listens to prayers and responds to them;[xxxiv] that God comforts us in our pain and cares for us when we are vulnerable and downtrodden.[xxxv] One of the most poignant elements of religious experience is repentance. A person can change his/her ways, and ask God for forgiveness; Jewish tradition asserts that God responds to true acts of repentance by turning past sins into merits.[xxxvi] A GPB of religious experience has personal relationships and therefore must be responsive; an immutable being in such a circumstance would not be as great as one who responded and could engage in dynamic relationships with people.

A potential solution that saves divine immutability while sustaining religious experience rests on a metaphor taught by Rabbi David Aaron, founder and teacher at Yeshivat Orayta, an Orthodox Jewish learning institution in Jerusalem for American gap-year students. Rabbi Aaron would tell his classes that there is music in the room and fall silent as the students looked at each other, not hearing anything. Rabbi Aaron would continue and explain that there are radio waves constantly moving through the room. If one would just have the right equipment and tune to the correct frequency, s/he would be able to experience the music that had been in the room all along. So too with God, if one views God’s will as constantly flowing, we just “tune in” to different aspects of God through our various actions. God is always immutable; we just experience God differently at different times because we access God in different ways.[xxxvii] For a Christian example, one can argue for immutability even in the act of incarnation by asserting that “God was eternally ready to be incarnate, and eternally had those experiences of the earthly Christ which the Incarnation makes part of his life. Through changes in Mary and the infant she bore, what was eternally in God eventually took place on earth.”[xxxviii] God’s essential will and presence is constant and immutable while its earthly manifestation changes in accordance with human actions.

Yet, this approach fails to truly comprehend the nuances of a relationship of love between God and humans that forms the foundation for religious experience. Cobb and Griffin, in arguing for God as responsive love, assert that “responsiveness includes a sympathetic feeling with the worldly beings.”[xxxix] For God to perfectly engage in loving relationships, God must possess “sympathetic compassion” for the other. An ideal relationship transcends “active goodwill”; it entails truly caring for the other and remaining sensitive and present through all circumstances.[xl] For something like repentance to truly have religious significance, it must entail a change in the individual and a response from God, a repair in this mutual relationship. The music metaphor does not adequately provide meaning to this process, because this relationship is one-sided: The penitent could change what aspect of God s/he accesses, but no mutual transformation occurs. This would be a flaw in the relationship, and as such, Divine responsiveness is a property that should replace immutability in the maximally perfect set of properties that the GPB would have to validate Morris’s claim that the GPB is the God of religion.

 

Bibliography

 

"A Living Library of Jewish Texts." Sefaria. Accessed Jan 12, 2020. www.sefaria.org/.

Adams, Marilyn McCord, and The Society of Christian Philosophers. “Fides Quaerens Intellectum: St. Anselm’s Method in Philosophical Theology.” Faith and Philosophy 9, no. 4 (1992): 409–35. https://doi.org/10.5840/faithphil19929434.

Chignell, Andrew and Daniel Rubio. "Religion and Reason." Lectures at Princeton

University, Sep.–Dec. 2019. Notes by Andrew Arking.

Cobb, John B. and David R. Griffin, “God is Creative-Responsive Love” in Process

Theology: An Introductory Exposition. Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1976.

Johnston, Mark. “Process Panentheism” in Saving God: Religion after Idolatry.

Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2009.

Leftow, Brian. “Immutability.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta, Winter 2016. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, 2016. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/immutability/.

Mann, William E. God, Modality, and Morality. Oxford University Press, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199370764.001.0001.

Morris, Thomas V. “The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Anselm.” Faith and Philosophy 1, no. 2 (1984): 177–187.

 

Acknowledgments     

 

            I would like to acknowledge Professors Chignell and Rubio for an excellent and thought-provoking course that has enhanced the way I think about and discuss my religious faith. I would further like to thank my teachers from Yeshivat Orayta for giving me feedback on these ideas, including Rabbi David Aaron for his teachings. Finally, I would like to appreciate Izzy Zaller for his conversations and for clarifying my understanding of many important topics.

Notes

 

 

 

[i] Andrew Chignell, “Religion and Reason,” 9/16/19.

[ii] Anselm, Proslogion 2, quoted in “Religion and Reason” lecture notes, 9/16/19.

[iii] Augustine, De Doctrina Christiana I,vi,6-vii, 7, quoted in “Religion and Reason” lecture notes, 9/16/19.

[iv] Adams and The Society of Christian Philosophers, “Fides Quaerens Intellectum.” 410.

[v] Morris, “The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Anselm.” 178.

[vi] Morris. 184.

[vii] Morris. 177.

[viii] Morris. 177.

[ix] Morris. 185.

[x] Chignell, 9/16/19.

[xi] Johnston, “Process Panentheism.” 195.

[xii] Morris, “The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Anselm.” 178.

[xiii] Morris. 186.

[xiv] Exodus 3:14.

[xv] Leftow, “Immutability.”

[xvi] Leftow.

[xvii] Ibid.

[xviii] Malachi 3:6.

[xix] Maimonides, Guide for the Perplexed Part 1, Chapter 11. www.sefaria.org.

[xx] Exodus 32:14.

[xxi] Ibn Ezra on Exodus 32:14. www.sefaria.org

[xxii] Kretzmann quoted in Leftow.

[xxiii] Daniel Rubio, 11/25/19.

[xxiv] Ibid.

[xxv] An allusion to Genesis 21:17: “God heard the cry of the boy [Ishmael], and an angel of God called to Hagar from heaven and said to her, “What troubles you, Hagar? Fear not, for God has heeded the cry of the boy in his present state.” The Talmud (Rosh Hashana 16b) learns from this verse the general principle that God judges a person according to his/her present state.

[xxvi] Genesis 6:6.

[xxvii] Akeidat Yitzhak 11:1.

[xxviii] Ibid.

[xxix] This may not be embodied emotions like humans possess, but God does change attitudes and actions based on our decisions.

[xxx] Talmud Sanhedrin 46a. Likutei Moharan 5. www.sefaria.org

[xxxi] Mann, God, Modality, and Morality.

[xxxii] Maimonides, Laws of Repentance Chapter 7.

[xxxiii] Deuteronomy 11.

[xxxiv] Exodus 3.

[xxxv] Isaiah 57:15.

[xxxvi] Yoma 86b.

[xxxvii] Rabbi David Aaron, The Secret Life of God; Seeing God; Lecture notes by Andrew Arking on classes from Nov. 2018.

[xxxviii] Leftow.

[xxxix] Cobb and Griffin, 378.

[xl] Ibid., 379.

Blessings and Curses: Thoughts for Parashat Lekh Lekha

 

Angel for Shabbat, Parashat Lekh Lekha

By Rabbi Marc D. Angel

“And I will make of you a great nation and I will bless you and make your name great and you will be a blessing. And I will bless those that bless you and curse the one who curses you; and through you all the families of the earth will be blessed” (Bereishith 12: 2-3).

God makes a lofty promise to Abram, assuring him that he will influence humanity in wonderful ways. His teachings will be a source of blessing to all the families of the earth. But God adds a caveat: He will bless all who bless Abram and will curse anyone who curses Abram.  Question: since Abram (later to be renamed Abraham) will be the epitome of righteousness and blessing, why would anyone want to curse him? 

God, in his infinite wisdom, knows human nature. No matter how good or wise a person is, there will always be detractors. Some are jealous; some are malicious; some are egotists who despise anyone who seems to surpass them in any way. God informs Abraham from the outset: you will do great things but you will also attract enemies who curse you. The road to greatness is not smooth. Many will appreciate you but others will do their best to defame you and block your way. They will curse you, spread lies about you, challenge your teachings, threaten you and your followers. Don’t be deterred. God will curse those who curse you—but what will this curse be?

I suggest that the curse is included in the very passage cited above: God will curse the curser when it is realized that through Abraham “all the families of the earth will be blessed.” The curser will become increasingly miserable and bitter as Abraham succeeds. With every blessing Abraham receives, the curser is stung with envy and anger.  It is an immense curse to have hatred and jealousy at the center of one’s life. Instead of living lovingly and generously, one suffers from a syndrome of internal decay.

God’s promises to Abraham have been fulfilled in many ways. Abraham’s descendants—the people of Israel—have been a remarkable source of blessing to humanity. The Hebrew Bible has vastly shaped western civilization. Individual Jews throughout history have provided humanity with vital insights in morality, science, literature, commerce, the arts etc. Although Jews are a minute fraction of humanity, the number of Jewish Nobel Prize winners and other top thinkers is astounding. (Google reports that Jewish individuals account for approximately 22% of all Nobel Prize winners globally since 1901, despite making up less than 0.2% of the world's population. 36-37% of American Nobel Prize winners are of Jewish ancestry, although Jews are about 2% of the American population.) The Jews of the State of Israel have created a dynamic democracy. Although a tiny nation (around 10 million people out of a world population of around 9 billion!), Israel is a world leader in technology, agriculture, defense, medicine and so many other fields. 

But as God foretold to Abram, there will always be cursers and haters who seek to diminish your achievements, undermine your teachings, and seek to destroy you. The cursers will indeed be cursed: their lives will be poisoned by hatred and envy, lies and self-destruction.

Those who bless Abraham will be blessed. They will live wholesome lives dedicated to righteousness and goodness. While the cursers stew in their jealousy and malice, the blessers will enjoy loving, generous lives.

God’s promises to Abram were true then. They are true today.

 

 

When Righteousness Isn't Enough: Thoughts for Parashat Noah

Angel for Shabbat, Parashat Noah

By Rabbi Marc D. Angel

In the first verse of this week’s Parasha, Noah is introduced as a righteous (tsadik) and whole-hearted (tamim) man. He was unique in his generation when “the earth was filled with violence.” The Almighty decided to wipe out humanity but to spare Noah and family. He commanded Noah to build an ark and provided exact specifications of what needed to be done. The Torah informs us that “Noah did according to that which God commanded him.” 

But then the Torah continues with God’s instruction to Noah to enter the ark with his family, “for I have seen you as righteous (tsadik) before Me in this generation.” Although Noah had followed God’s commands exactly, he was now called tsadik (righteous) but no longer tamim (whole-hearted).  It seems that God noticed a defect in Noah’s behavior and demoted him accordingly.

But what was the defect? Noah had done exactly as commanded. Why was he no longer tamim? Why was he no longer described as being “whole-hearted?”

What is the chief characteristic of a tsadik?  A tsadik acts with tsedek, justice.  Rules are followed, commitments are kept. The Talmud (Pesahim 8a-b) discusses the case of a father who prays for the health of an ill child. If the father states that he will give charity on condition that God will heal the child, the father is considered to be totally righteous (tsadik gamur). Yet, this prayer seems far from ideal. Why should the father be deemed righteous by making a bargain with God? Rabbi Hayyim Yosef Azulai, a great sage of the 18th century, commented: The father is righteous—but not pious. Righteousness entails making commitments and keeping them. The father strikes a bargain that he intends to fulfill exactly. But he lacks piety.

What is the chief characteristic of a tamim? A tamim is whole-hearted, pure, pious. A tamim doesn’t simply follow rules but operates with a much larger religious vision. At the beginning of the Parasha, Noah is described as having both qualities—a tsadik and a tamim. When God commanded Noah to build the ark, he did so exactly as he was instructed. He was a tsadik. But God had expected more than mere righteousness; He wanted whole-heartedness, love, piety. Yes, Noah followed instructions; but why didn’t he first pray to God and ask forgiveness for the people? Why didn’t he demonstrate feelings of human solidarity? Why didn’t he challenge God as Abraham and Moses did in later generations?

Noah, in following the rules as a tsadik, did not maintain his quality of being a tamim. Religion demands both proper conduct and proper sentiment--adherence to the demands of justice and a grand religious vision characterized by love of God and humanity. God expected Noah—and us—to be not only righteous but to be whole-hearted, pure, loving, visionary. Are we up to it?

 

 

 

Paired Perspectives on the Parashah: Noah

Noah:

The Tower of Babel

 

The Tower of Babel occupies only nine verses in the Torah, yet it is the only narrative between the Flood and the introduction of Abraham’s family. Its prominent placement suggests that it marks a critical turning point in human history. However, the Torah never explicitly identifies the sin of the builders. What exactly did they do wrong, and why did God intervene so dramatically?

The Talmud (Sanhedrin 109a) maintains that the builders rebelled against God. Some sought to ascend to heaven and wage war against Him, while others intended to worship idols. Rabbi Nathan concludes that all of the builders were motivated by idolatry. This interpretation explains the severity of God’s response, but it is difficult to establish from the biblical text itself. The people simply declare their intention to build a city and a tower reaching toward heaven, thereby making a name for themselves and preventing their dispersion (Genesis 11:4).

Ibn Ezra emphatically rejects the notion that the builders literally intended to ascend to heaven. They were not so foolish as to believe that a tower could reach God’s dwelling place. Rather, they wanted to establish a permanent city, with an impressive tower serving as a landmark and a monument to their achievements. Their desire to remain together, however, conflicted with God’s plan that humanity populate the entire earth (Genesis 1:28; 9:1). According to Ibn Ezra, the builders did not necessarily intend to rebel against God. They simply pursued their own aspirations without recognizing that these aspirations contradicted God’s will.

Other commentators offer variations on these approaches. Radak and Bekhor Shor understand the refusal to disperse as a deliberate rejection of God’s plan for people to populate the earth. Hizkuni and Netziv perceive a more sinister dimension in the people’s insistence on unity, suggesting that their society suppressed individuality and freedom. These interpretations offer important insights into the dangers of human ambition and enforced conformity. Nevertheless, the biblical narrative does not explicitly identify any of these offenses.

The twentieth-century biblical scholar Umberto Cassuto offers a compelling interpretation by placing the narrative within its ancient Mesopotamian setting. His approach enables us to appreciate the significance of details that otherwise seem incidental, while also bringing us back to the Talmud’s interpretation.

Ancient Babylonian cities featured monumental stepped towers known as ziggurats, associated with temples dedicated to their gods. These towers symbolically connected heaven and earth. The Babylonians viewed these sacred structures as symbolic meeting places between heaven and earth, where the divine realm could intersect with the human world. The towers thus reflected a religious worldview in which people sought to establish contact with, and exercise influence over, the divine realm.

The most famous Babylonian ziggurat was associated with the temple of Marduk in Babylon. Its name, Etemenanki, meant “House of the Foundation of Heaven and Earth.” Babylonian traditions attributed the construction of the sacred complex to the gods themselves. The city of Babylon likewise was understood as Bab-ilim, “Gate of the God,” reflecting its inhabitants’ conviction that their city was a center of divine presence.

With this background, several unusual features of the Torah’s account become intelligible. Why does the narrative devote an entire verse to the process of manufacturing bricks? Because monumental construction in Mesopotamia depended upon baked bricks rather than the stone commonly used elsewhere. Why does the Torah emphasize that the tower was built by human beings (Genesis 11:5)? Because Babylonian religious tradition attributed its sacred construction to the gods. Most strikingly, why does God need to “descend” to inspect a tower supposedly reaching heaven? The Torah employs biting irony. No matter how impressive human architecture may be, it cannot bring people closer to God or compel Him to appear. God remains utterly transcendent and free.

Even the name Babylon becomes part of the Torah’s theological critique. The Babylonians celebrated their city as the gateway to the divine realm. The Torah instead associates Bavel with the Hebrew root balal, meaning confusion (Genesis 11:9). What the Babylonians regarded as the center of cosmic order becomes, in the Torah’s account, the place where human unity collapses.

Cassuto’s interpretation thus illuminates the Talmud’s striking assertion that the builders engaged in idolatry and rebellion against God. The Sages expressed their interpretation through the dramatic imagery of ascending to heaven and waging war against God. The ancient Near Eastern evidence suggests that their underlying theological insight was remarkably perceptive. The builders sought to bridge the boundary between humanity and divinity through their own monumental achievements. Their error was not technological innovation itself, but the presumption that human beings could control access to God.

This interpretation also clarifies why the Tower of Babel appears immediately before the emergence of Abraham. Humanity’s attempt to establish a religious center through its own power ends in confusion and dispersion. God then chooses Abraham to begin a different religious journey, one founded upon obedience to God rather than the manipulation of divine power.

Rabbi Hayyim Angel's New Book: The Heart of Joshua

We are thrilled to announce that Rabbi Hayyim Angel has published the second volume of his new commentary series, The Heart of Tanakh. The Heart of Joshua joins the Heart of the Five Megillot. 

 

On the way over the next several months: Judges, 1 Samuel, 2 Samuel, 1 Kings, and 2 Kings (and then more to follow after that!). 

In The Heart of Joshua, Rabbi Hayyim Angel draws on classical rabbinic interpretation, literary analysis, and contemporary scholarship to illuminate the enduring power of the first book of the Prophets.

Written for thoughtful readers, students, educators, clergy, and synagogue study groups, this volume invites readers to engage the Book of Joshua with intellectual rigor, spiritual sensitivity, and a deep appreciation for the richness of the Jewish interpretive tradition.

 

 

Available at amazon.com

 

 

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HJD2VY4L/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1XWH0J6ECVCB3&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.vQ7BXEIlShrrcUruBSwBN-_UISmOKX0iobElLtg5jAkfpTV4inCL3A-Fq50…

 

Remembering Kristallnacht

The unprecedented pogrom of November 9-10, 1938 in Germany has passed into history as Kristallnacht (Night of Broken Glass). Violent attacks on Jews and Judaism throughout the Reich and in the recently annexed Sudetenland began on November 8 and continued until November 11 in Hannover and the free city of Danzig, which had not then been incorporated into the Reich. There followed associated operations: arrests, detention in concentration camps, and a wave of so-called Aryanization orders, which completely eliminated Jews from German economic life.

The November pogrom, carried out with the help of the most up-to-date communications technology, was the most modern pogrom in the history of anti-Jewish persecution and an overture to the step-by-step extirpation of the Jewish people in Europe.

Jews Leaving Germany

After Hitler’s seizure of power, even as Germans were being divided into “Aryans” and “non-Aryans,” the number of Jews steadily decreased through emigration to neighboring countries or overseas. This movement was promoted by the Central Office for Jewish Emigration established by Reinhard Heydrich (director of the Reich Main Security Office) in 1938.

In 1925 there were 564,378 Jews in Germany; in May 1939 the number had fallen to 213,390. The flood of emigration after the November pogrom was one of the largest ever, and by the time emigration was halted in October 1941, only 164,000 Jews were left within the Third Reich, including Austria.

The illusion that the legal repression enacted in the civil service law of April 1, 1933, which excluded non-Aryans from public service, would be temporary was laid to rest in September 1935 by the Nuremberg Laws — the Reich Citizenship Law and the Law for the Protection of German Blood and Honor. The Reich Citizenship Law heralded the political compartmentalization of Jewish and Aryan Germans.

 

Desecrated Synagogues, Looted Shops, Mass Arrests

During the night of November 9-10, 1938 Jewish shops, dwellings, schools, and above all synagogues and other religious establishments symbolic of Judaism were set alight. Tens of thousands of Jews were terrorized in their homes, sometimes beaten to death, and in a few cases raped. In Cologne, a town with a rich Jewish tradition dating from the first century CE, four synagogues were desecrated and torched, shops were destroyed and looted, and male Jews were arrested and thrown into concentration camps.

Brutal events were recorded in the hitherto peaceful townships of the Upper Palatinate, Lower Franconia, Swabia, and others. In Hannover, Herschel Grynszpan‘s hometown, the well-known Jewish neurologist Joseph Loewenstein escaped the pogrom when he heeded an anonymous warning the previous day; his home, however, with all its valuables, was seized by the Nazis.

In Berlin, where 140,000 Jews still resided, SA men devastated nine of the 12 synagogues and set fire to them. Children from the Jewish orphanages were thrown out on the street. About 1,200 men were sent to Oranienburg-Sachsenhausen concentration camp under “protective custody.” Many of the wrecked Jewish shops did not open again.

Following the Berlin pogrom the police president demanded the removal of all Jews from the northern parts of the city and declared this area “free of Jews.” His order on December 5, 1938 — known as the Ghetto Decree — meant that Jews could no longer live near government buildings.

The vast November pogrom had considerable economic consequences. On November 11, 1938 Heydrich, the head of the security police, still could not estimate the material destruction. The supreme party court later established that 91 persons had been killed during the pogrom and that 36 had sustained serious injuries or committed suicide. Several instances of rape were punished by state courts as Rassenschande (social defilement) in accordance with the Nuremberg laws of 1935.

At least 267 synagogues were burned down or destroyed, and in many cases the ruins were blown up and cleared away. Approximately 7,500 Jewish businesses were plundered or laid waste. At least 177 apartment blocks or houses were destroyed by arson or otherwise.

It has rightly been said that with the November pogrom, radical violence had reached the point of murder and so had paved the road to Auschwitz.

Reprinted with permission from The Holocaust Encyclopedia (Yale University Press).

 

When Will the Glass Overflow?

 

“In a world where everything is seen, nothing is known. 
In a world where everything is known, nothing is understood.”

 — Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks

 

Living in Israel in an era that surely lays claim to bringing us closer to redemption than previous generations could have imagined, I see the glass as very much more than half full. Yet the upper part remains to be filled, and there are many issues to be faced—some propitious, some daunting—before we can hope to see it overflow.

Depending on how you count, it is probable that more than half of the world’s Jews now live in Israel. This has some implications in halakha, specifically regarding laws relating to the Land of Israel, such as yovel and shemittah, which revert from their lesser status as rabbinic obligations (de-rabbanan),  and once again take on the character of biblical obligations (de-oraita), “as in days of old.” 

Looking ahead to the coming years, we will increasingly see Israel as the powerhouse of Jewish life. That is not to say that Jewish life in the diaspora will wither away. But with the dwindling numbers of grassroots adherents of the non-Orthodox movements, national Jewish institutions will more often be led by members of the Modern Orthodox community. The Haredi world, even as it continues to grow in numbers, is likely to stubbornly persist in isolating itself from Jewish issues outside of its own enclaves and will steadfastly focus its attention and resources only on its own educational systems and communal structures.

The pervasive and unabated anti-Semitism in the diaspora, combined with the relentless attacks on Israel, have already motivated many unaffiliated Jews to search for more spiritual meaning in their Judaism, and this is gradually leading increasing numbers to embrace more observances and to seek more knowledge. As it is, the amount of Torah being learned today far eclipses any other time in history. With online programs already connecting hundreds of thousands to the study of Jewish sources, the opportunities for Torah learning on every level will become even more extensive with the still uncharted capabilities of artificial intelligence. 

On the other hand, it is exceedingly worrisome that a recent survey found that as many as 32 percent of Jewish Americans aged 18 to 34 call themselves anti-Zionists or non-Zionists. Given that, it’s unclear how connected they will remain to their Jewish heritage. Sadly, these young people, together with those who intermarry or those who are raised with no Jewish content in their lives—and together with all their descendants—may well be lost to the future of the Jewish people.

In Israel, the schisms that plague society will regrettably grow in intensity. As the Haredi sector defiantly pursues its intransigence and refuses to play its part in the support and defense of the nation, the patience of Israel’s secular citizens will inevitably run out. While it will probably be short of actual civil war, the conflict is likely to become increasingly ugly and confrontational, with the government, as now, unwilling or unable to exert control.

Unfortunately, Yehoram Gaon’s poignant promise in song following the 1973 Yom Kippur War that “this will be the last war” is unlikely ever to become true. Israel’s enemies plot and attack it at every opportunity because of an unwavering religious belief that one day they will be able to destroy it. They can fight and lose a hundred wars, they say, while Israel cannot afford to lose even one. 

With all this, Israelis consistently rank in the top five or ten on the UN World Happiness Report. This is often attributed to their strong social cohesion and sense of purpose, and there is no reason to think that this will change. Despite the too-frequent runs to the safe rooms and bomb shelters, despite the huge disruptions in family life and income due to the extended periods spent in the army, despite the tumultuous way in which the nation is governed, Israelis are proud of their country and will assuredly continue to walk around with their heads high and their spirits even higher.

With all of its existential challenges, or perhaps because of them, Israel’s extraordinary success as a world leader in innovative technology will continue undiminished. The abundant income generated by the nation’s multitudinous start-ups will go on helping to underwrite the costs of Israel’s infrastructure and innumerable other construction projects, and indeed its wars. Transferring ownership of these assets out of Israel by means of “exits” is not ideal and presents a challenge to the country’s long-term economic stability, but the Israeli genius will not be suppressed and will continue to attract the attention and investment of other countries and multinational conglomerates.

The disparity among Israel’s various subcultures will increasingly blur as marriages between Ashkenazic and Sephardic families proliferate. One might hope that this would lead to the merging of minhagim into one universal Israeli set of religious customs and practices, but the religious establishment is extremely unlikely to brook any formalized change. Similarly, a logical consequence of Israel’s astounding, God-given rebirth as a nation would be a creative rethinking of parts of the siddur to reflect the enormous theological implications of this new status. Again, the religious authorities will not even contemplate such a notion. Yet there are pockets of creative religious thinkers whose influence may slowly spread.

As we cross the threshold where the majority of our people now live once again in our ancestral land, we continue to see the evolution from a rabbinically-led existence, concerned largely about survival in often hostile foreign countries, to the complex realities of a modern, self-governing state. This will inevitably contribute to the already growing gap between Israeli Jews and those in the diaspora. Yet Israel will never abandon its efforts to bolster Jewish communities and to further Jewish education in other lands as best it can.

The road ahead, both in Israel and in the diaspora, is full of hurdles due to the threats from external enemies on the one hand, and the stubbornness of established institutions and religious extremists on the other. Yet it is precisely within these tensions that the next chapter of Jewish history is being written—not in the margins of other nations, but at the center of our own. 

Living in our own land offers us a glimpse of a glass that is revayah—full, dynamic and, eventually, running over.

 

Reclaiming the Battlefield of Tanakh in Jewish-Christian Debate


For nearly two thousand years, Christian theology has presented itself as the fulfillment
of the Hebrew Bible. Incarnation, divine sonship, vicarious atonement, and Trinitarian theology
are all claimed to be latent within Tanakh—awaiting recognition.


Jewish responses have typically taken one of two paths.


Some attempt to refute Christianity by engaging it on its own turf: analyzing the New
Testament, dissecting Greek terminology, critiquing Church history, or debating early Christian
councils. Others retreat from engagement altogether, assuming that faith alone is sufficient
insulation.

Both approaches are flawed.

The first is strategically misguided. The second is intellectually insufficient.
This article proposes a third approach: return the debate to Tanakh—and only to Tanakh.
If Christianity cannot establish its doctrines from the Hebrew Bible, then its claim to be
the fulfillment of Judaism collapses at the foundation. A Jew does not need to master the New
Testament in order to defend Judaism. But Christianity, by definition, must root itself in the “Old
Testament.” That asymmetry is decisive.
 

We do not need their texts.
They need ours.
And that is where the conversation must remain.


The Method: Let Tanakh Stand on Its Own
The method is simple:
1. Argue from Tanakh alone.
2. Prioritize peshat (plain meaning).
3. Avoid dependence on rabbinic commentary 1 or later mystical speculation.
4. Do not engage in New Testament critique.
5. Demand textual clarity, not theological inference.
If doctrines like incarnation or Trinity are genuinely rooted in Tanakh, they should be
unequivocally demonstrable from the text itself—in context, linguistically, and covenantally.
They should not require
● Hidden codes
● Retrospective reinterpretation
● Ambiguous pronoun counting

● Mystical letter symbolism
● Post-biblical theological overlays
Tanakh is not cryptic about its core doctrines.
When it introduces covenant.
When it introduces kingship.
When it introduces sacrifice.
When it introduces prophecy.
It speaks clearly.
If incarnation were foundational, it would not appear as a grammatical anomaly in a poetic verse.
Example 1: “Let Us Make Man”—The Trinity Claim
Bereishit 1:26 is frequently cited:
“Let us make man in our image, after our likeness.”
The argument: the plural “us” indicates plurality within God.
But Tanakh itself supplies the interpretive framework. Isaiah 6 describes God as
surrounded by the heavenly court. I Kings, 22 depicts God consulting celestial beings. 2 Isaiah
8:8 3 does the same. Ancient Near Eastern royal language frequently includes deliberative plural
speech.
The text never hints at ontological plurality.
If this verse were teaching a triune metaphysics, it would be the most opaque doctrinal
introduction in all of Tanakh.
Instead, the next verse reverts immediately to singular form:
“And God created man in His image.”
No explanation. No doctrinal development. No clarification.
To build Nicene theology through pronoun counting is not textual reading. It is
theological projection.
Example 2: Isaiah 53—The Suffering Servant
Isaiah 53 is often treated as the decisive Christian prooftext.
But by chapter 53 Isaiah has already identified the servant explicitly and repeatedly:
“But you, Israel, My servant…” (41:8)
“Hear, O Jacob My servant…” (44:1)
“You are My servant, Israel…” (49:3)
By the time we reach chapter 53, the servant’s identity has already been fixed within the
book’s own narrative structure.
To switch identities in midstream without textual signal is not exegesis; it is retrofitting.
Even within Isaiah 53 itself, you find:
“He will see offspring and prolong his days.”

Christian interpretation must spiritualize this, because Jesus had no biological offspring.
Judaism, however, reads it plainly.
That is not polemic.
That is textual fidelity.
Example 3: Messianic Criteria
Tanakh describes the Messiah’s role clearly:
● Global peace (Isaiah 2, 11)
● Universal knowledge of G-d (Jeremiah 31)
● Restoration of Torah observance (Ezekiel 37)
● Rebuilding the Temple (Ezekiel 37)
● Gathering exiles (Isaiah 11)
● Davidic patrilineal descent (II Samuel 7)
These are measurable outcomes.
Tanakh does not say: He will come, fail, die, and return millennia later.
If the Messiah must fulfill criteria, and those criteria were not fulfilled, Tanakh’s definition
governs.
A “second coming” is not a Tanakh-based category.
Is Christianity Shituf (syncretism), Avodah Zarah (idolatry), Henotheism, or Monotheism?
The Critical Error In Mischaracterizing Christianity
Before engaging Christian claims from Tanakh, we must first clarify how Christianity is
categorized in halakhic and theological terms. Sloppy labels undermine serious argument. If we
call it paganism when it does not define itself that way, we lose credibility. If we collapse
complex halakhic distinctions into slogans, we forfeit strategic clarity.
This section therefore addresses four critical questions:
1. What is shituf in halakha, and how does it function in polemics?
2. How do later authorities treat Christianity within the framework of “religion-bound
nations”?
3. Is Christianity accurately described as henotheism?
4. Does the Rambam’s polemical description actually match Christianity’s self-definition?
These distinctions are not semantic. They determine whether we argue carefully from
Tanakh—or begin the debate already on the defensive.
1) Shituf in Halakha: What It Is, And Why It Matters in Christian Polemics

In halakhic literature, shituf refers to attaching something else to God in
worship—invoking a “partner,” mediator, or composite divine framework – such that worship is
no longer directed to God alone. 4 The category is not merely philosophical; it functions
halakhically as a boundary-marker for what a Jew may affirm, invoke, or validate.
Rambam: Christianity as Avodah Zarah For Jews
Rambam treats Christian theology as avodah zarah (idolatry) from a Jewish standpoint, i.e., a
Jew is forbidden to frame God in Trinitarian terms, and certainly forbidden to worship through
that framework. (This is part of his broader project of protecting absolute, uncompromised
unity.)
See Rambam Hilkhot Avodat Kokhavim, 5 where he sets out the Torah’s prohibition
against worshipping through any “foreign” framework, and the halakhic posture that flows from
it.
At the same time, Rambam famously recognizes that Christianity has played a role in
spreading knowledge of the Creator across the world 6 —though that sociological point does not
reduce the halakhic prohibition for Jews.
Tosafot & Rema: Shituf and Non-Jews
A major axis in the halakhic discussion is whether shituf is prohibited for non-Jews.
Tosafot in their commentary on shituf, 7 do not define shituf philosophically.
They describe it functionally: Invoking God together with something else.
They even add:
“They do not consider them gods.”
That line is critical. Tosafot acknowledge that gentiles do not think they are worshipping
multiple gods. Yet halakhically, it is still called shituf.
That nuance is extremely important when engaging with Christians, so as to not
mischaracterize their religion as non-monotheistic.
The Rema then codifies this principle in a practical halakhic context, that a non-Jew’s
oath can be accepted even though “they mention the Name of Heaven and another thing,”
because their intent is toward the Creator, adding that shituf is not prohibited to them. 8
The Bottom Line
From a halakhic perspective, the operative question is not “do Christians claim
monotheism?”—they do. The operative question is: Does their formulation violate the Torah’s
demand for the unity of God as understood by halakha, and if so, does that prohibition apply
equally to non-Jews?
2) Later Approaches That Treat Christianity as “Religion-Bound Nations” Rather Than
Classic Idolaters

Once you move beyond the Rambam’s strict philosophical-halakhic posture, you find an
additional track in the posekim and ba’alei machshavah: not redefining Christian doctrine as
“kosher,” but reclassifying Christians sociologically/halakhically as part of the “religion-bound”
world rather than pagan idolaters.
Meiri: “Nations Bound by the Ways of Religion”
The Meiri is often cited for distinguishing between pagans and what he describes as
civilizations governed by religion and morality, where belief in one transcendent Creator is
central. 9 The Meiri’s exact wording for such people is: “But any nation that is bound by the ways
of religion and acknowledges divinity – there is no doubt that even if one does not know him
personally, it is permitted and proper [to act toward him differently].” 10
In this approach, Christianity is treated very differently than the idolaters discussed in many
talmudic passages—less as “classic avodah zarah culture” and more as a mistaken theology
within a monotheistic religious civilization.
An Important Nuance
Notice in the key passage mentioned above:
● They acknowledge divinity.
● Meiri does not say they have perfect theology.
● Meiri does not say they affirm God’s unity properly.
Rather, he is making a halakhic-sociological distinction. He is saying that these nations are
religiously structured and morally bound. Therefore, they are not treated like ancient pagan
idolaters.
This Meiri-frame essentially states that belief in a single transcendent God is what moves
Christianity outside the simple category of avodah zarah.
The Bottom Line
Even within Orthodox sources, one can find models that speak of Christianity as:
● theologically incorrect, yet
● religiously oriented toward the Creator, and
● certainly not equivalent to paganism.
3) Is Christianity Henotheism?
No—at least not in the standard definition. 11

Henotheism is worship of the one God without denying other gods.
Nicene Christianity 12 does not present itself as worshipping the one God among many; it presents
itself as one God with an internal tri-personal structure.
So if the goal is persuasive accuracy, one shouldn’t call it henotheism. The critique is different:
it’s about whether their “complex unity” preserves Torah’s framing of God’s unity or violates it.
4) Rambam’s Description Doesn’t Match Christianity as Christians Define It
Here is the key move you want for apologetics strategy:
Rambam’s Polemical Description of Christianity in Iggeret Teiman
In his Iggeret Teiman, 13 the Rambam describes Jesus as someone who:
1. persuaded people that he was a prophet sent by God, and
2. presented himself as the Messiah, and
3. interpreted Torah in a way that led to “the total annulment…the abolition of all its
commandments.”
This is an explicit summary of what the Rambam thought Christian doctrine entails.
The Apologetic Point: Rambam’s Description Is Not Christianity’s Self-definition
But this is precisely where a careful Christian polemicist can counter:
● Nicene Christianity does not define Jesus as merely a “prophet sent by God.” It defines
him as fully divine (“true God from true God”), and grounds this in the doctrine of
Trinity and incarnation. 14
● The Nicene Creed opens with “We/I believe in one God,” and then immediately defines
Jesus in divine terms, i.e., their claim is not “two gods,” but one God in a tri-personal
framework. 15
● Likewise, Christianity typically does not say “Torah is simply abolished.” It argues a
fulfillment/reframing model (often the Torah’s “moral law remains; ritual law is
fulfilled/transformed”), 16 which, while completely unfounded in the Torah, is not
identical to the Rambam’s phrasing that Jesus sought “total annulment” of mitzvot.
Why This Matters
The previous point serves not to diminish Rambam. It is simply methodological:
When Jews cite “shituf” or “avodah zarah” claims sloppily, Christians will answer: “We
unequivocally affirm one God.”
And here the evidence is straightforward: their own creed explicitly frames their
belief as monotheistic, even while defining God in a way Judaism rejects.
The apologetics takeaway: don’t mischaracterize—categorize:

● Don’t argue “they’re not monotheists.” They will instantly quote their creed and the
conversation shifts to your credibility.
● Do argue: “Even granting your claim of one God, Tanakh defines God’s oneness in a way
that excludes incarnation/divine man/divine mediation and forbids directing worship
through/alongside any other referent.”
That keeps you firmly on Tanakh-based ground (the entire debate method of this essay), and it
prevents the debate from turning into a meta-fight about whether you’ve even read Christian
sources.
A Final Thought: Bringing the Debate Onto Jewish Turf
This is the core strategic insight:
When Jews debate Christianity from Christian texts, they play defense.
When Jews demand proof from Tanakh, they control the field.
Christian theology cannot detach itself from the Hebrew Bible. It requires it.
Judaism can defend itself entirely within Tanakh.
That asymmetry must be preserved.
One faithful to Torah does not need to master Greek Christology to defend emunah. He needs to
know his own inheritance.
If incarnation is real, show it in Tanakh.
If the Trinity is real, show it in Tanakh.
If a dying messiah who suspends Torah is real, show it in Tanakh.
Not in church councils.
Not in mystical overlays.
Not in typological readings centuries later.
In Tanakh.
…and if it is not there, it is not there.

1 This methodological choice is strategic, not theological. Christian polemicists often claim that
the Rabbis “suppressed,” “buried,” or “reinterpreted away” messianic prophecies that originally
pointed to Jesus or to Trinitarian theology. Although this claim is unfounded, once the debate
shifts to whether Hazal distorted the text, the discussion becomes a historical argument about
rabbinic authority rather than a textual examination of Tanakh itself. Therefore, for the purposes
of interfaith debate, the method here must be deliberately simple: read the Tanakh on its own
terms. If incarnation, Trinity, or a dying-and-returning messiah are genuinely embedded in the
Hebrew Bible, they should be demonstrable from the plain text—without appealing to a single
rabbinic commentary. If these claims cannot unequivocally be shown there, the burden has not
been met.
2 “I saw God sitting on His throne, and all the host of heaven standing by Him…”
3 “Who will go for us?”

4 Tosafot, Sanhedrin 63b.
5 Rambam, Hilkhot Avodat Kokhavim 2:1–3.
6 Rambam Hilkhot Melakhim 11:4.
7 Tosafot, Sanhedrin 63b.
8 Rema Orah Hayyim 156:1.
9 Meiri, on Avodah Zarah 20a.
10 Ibid.
11 See Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. “Henotheism”.
12 Nicene Creed.
13 Rambam, Iggeret Teiman, Iggerot HaRambam.
14 Nicene Creed.
15 Ibid.
16 Matthew 5:17.